Donation of Constantine
The Donation of Constantine was a document which purported to show that Emperor Constantine the Great had ceded the territory and regalia of the Roman Empire to Pope Sylvester in expiation for his sins; Sylvester then returned the gift to the Emperor. The document was used at various times of political tension between a pope and a secular ruler to claim that the popes had not only spiritual but also temporal authority. The document was a forgery of the late 8th century and was demonstrated as such by Lorenzo Valla in the 15th century1 See: http://history.hanover.edu/texts/vallatc.html.
It is generally accepted that the document was created around 750 in the context of papal attempts to escape from the authority of the Byzantine Empire. By asserting that they had both temporal and spiritual authority, the Popes could refuse to comply with directives coming from Constantinople. Given the military weakness of the Empire in Italy at the time, they could do this without fear of repercussions. Nevertheless, they needed protection from the threat posed by an aggressive Lombard kingdom which had recently overrun the Exarchate of Ravenna, one of the few remaining major holdings of the Empire in Italy. Having supported and endorsed Pépin le Bref’s successful bid to become King of the Franks, Pope Stephen II used the Donation document to convince Pépin to retake the Byzantine lands captured by the Lombards and to hand them over to him rather than returning them to their original owners.
The source of the story used in the Donation was the Legenda sancti Sylvestri, an anonymous document of the late fifth century, also a time of tension between Rome and Constantinople. The intent of the Legenda was to legitimise the transfer of the imperial capital to Constantinople. It describes how, at the moment of his conversion to Christianity, Constantine prostrated himself before Pope Sylvester in expiation of his sins. Sylvester was offered all the imperial regalia (including the Crown) but he returned them to Constantine; the implication being that Constantine held office as Roman Emperor with the acquiescence and agreement of the Pope, similarly with the establishment of Constantinople as the imperial capital. There is no shred of evidence for any of this story whose events, had they been true, would have taken place some 150 years prior to the creation of the document. Nevertheless, it was widely believed to be true.
What was merely implied in the Legenda was made specific in the Donation which stated that Constantine wished ‘to give the Roman Church imperial power and dignity of glory, vigour, and honour’. To do this, Constantine handed over to Sylvester not only the imperial regalia as described in the Legenda but also the imperial palace to be his residence, as well as the city of Rome, all provinces of Italy and the West as a whole. By returning everything to Constantine, Sylvester signified that it was all his by right and that it could be withdrawn at any moment. Stephen II successfully used the Donation to convince Pépin to do his bidding as he and later Frankish rulers had a genuine veneration for the Church.
The authenticity of the Donation of Constantine was questioned at the end of the 10th century by the Emperor Otto III but it continued to be used, notably by Pope Leo IX in 1054, leading to the Great Schism between the Eastern and Western churches. In 1430, the German humanist Nicolas of Cusa again cast doubts on the authenticity of the Donation but it was left to Lorenzo Valla a few years later to provide the definitive proof of the forgery.
Sources for this page are Ullmann 1965 and 2003. See also: Donation of Constantine which contains a section of the relevant text.
![]()
- 1