The Papacy as a Political Actor
Principal source: Ullmann 2003
The origins of the papacy as a secular authority
Although not considered to be any different from other churches at the time of the legalisation of Christianity in the Roman Empire (313), as the 4th century progressed the Roman church began to be considered as the leading authority in spiritual matters. At this time, Roman theological authority did not extend to governance; no church was to interfere in the affairs of another and all churches were subordinate to the emperor (who also carried the title of pontifex maximus). However, successive popes began to use the language of Roman law and secular institutions, thus enhancing claims to superiority over others. Another important strand was the contention that Christ had bestowed authority over the Church to St. Peter who was supposedly the founder and first leader of the Roman church.
The failure of Constantinople to support Rome at the time by its sack by the Visigoths in 410 resulted in the papacy becoming a locus for secular authority. The tone of papal pronouncements increased accordingly, with Celestine I (422-432) declaring that decretals had the force of law. Moses was used as an exemplar of an overarching authority and the concept that the law was of divine origin was reinforced by stating that its source was the Bible, rather the accumulation of custom and practice. The assertion of papal dominance reached its apogee in the reign of Leo I the Great (440-461). A jurist, Leo used Roman law to institutionalise the papacy, separating the office from the individual who occupied it. The pope was the legal heir of St. Peter and his acts and pronouncements had the force of law. The positions of the pope and the emperor were similar (both principati) but the imperial office was a human creation wheras the papal office a divine one and hence superior to it. By contrast, the position of the Byzantine (and later German) emperors was that the emperor was God’s representative on Earth and that his coronation (by pope or patriarch) was merely an act confirming an already existing reality. This fundamental incompatibility of these two positions was at the heart of all subsequent conflicts between the religious and secular authorities.
The last decades of the 5th century saw the continuation of the assertion of papal authority. An important document in support of this was Legenda sancti Sylvestri (written in the 480s). This described how the Emperor Constantine had laid the trappings of his Empire at the feet of Pope Silvester and had then received them back again (implying that emperors’ authority derived from the Church). There was no evidence for this but the document was an important source for the 8th century Donation of Constantine, an equally spurious document used to assert papal dominance until definitively debunked in the 15th century.
Some text to test the post id.
The Franks
Conversion of Clovis (496?) the beginning of the relationship with popes. Franks accepted authority of the church.
![]()