Notes: Spufford Power and Profit: The Merchant in Medieval Europe
Source: Spufford, P., Power and Profit: The Merchant in Medieval Europe (London: Thames & Hudson, 2002)
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Page | Note |
|---|---|
| 38 | Local banking developed same time as international banking. Interlocking banking systems – Florence the leader – as many as 80 banks by the early 14th century. |
| 39 | Instructions to banks initially oral but development of checks – earliest surviving checks from Pisa and Florence (Florence 1368). Use became banal (1477 – haberdasher pays for emptying cesspit by cheque). |
| 39 | Deposit accounts paid interest for long-term deposits (e.g. future diaries) as capital used to finance long-term enterprises (Venice-Levant-Venice). The Flanders-Venice trip took two years. |
| 44 | Lending for investment in a commercial enterprise not seen as usury (whereas loans were seen as taking advantage of someone's bad luck). Increase in lending lowered interest rates – making more investment possible. Beginning of the 13th century: rates +/-20%, hundred years later 7%. |
| 44-45 | Prestanze paid interest but at lower rates and therefore traded below par. |
| 47 | Definition of a staple town: place where trade in a product could only be made with a local and not elsewhere. |
| 48 | Restrictive practices in staple towns raised transaction costs. Restrictions in London resulted in the Italians using Southampton. |
| 53 | Instruction manual for trading (standard text rather than individual compilations) probably put together in Florence in the 1420s. Libro di Mercantie goes through three editions and printed by the end of the 15th century. In 1494, it was incorporated into Pacioli's 'Summa de Arithmetica'. |
| 53 | Importance of the earlier notebooks of Francesco Pegolotti who worked for the Bardi (1300-1340). Very comprehensive. |
| 58 | Where dominant political individuals were engaged in commercial activities, business was a preoccupation for the government, unlike in traditional monarchies such as France. Resulted in favourable tax regimes, public investment in infrastructure. Emphasis on indirect taxation – favours capital accumulation rather than spending. But also regressive as most taxes were on essentials. Collection of such taxes not easily disrupted by foreign wars or restrictions. |
| 67 | Income of Florence: 1240 – 26,000 lire; hundred years later 942,000 lire – an eleven fold increase |
| 105 | The large population in northern Italy created difficulties in finding enough food – grain, wine and oil imported via Venice, Genoa and Pisa. Meat raised in Hungary and then driven to Aquileia hinterland and then fattened. Importance of mutton for Tuscany – driven from southern Italy. By the 1320s, Florence was the third largest city in Italy (120,000). |
| 106 | The years before the Black Death marked the highest point in the population of Florence. Thereafter it was hit by continual waves of plague. By 1400, the population was only one third of what it had been in the 1330s despite massive migration from the contado. Problems in providing food eased by the use of larger ships. |
| 174 | Collapse of the Roman road system – nadir in the 12th century. |
| 181 | 13th century saw a revival of bridge building and road improvements… |
| 181-182 | … In northern Italy, city states began improvements as early as the 12th century but only really took off in the 13th. |
| 182 | Previously, the collapse of bridges and embankments had led to the abandonment of low-lying Roman roads for circuitous ones on higher ground. General absence of effective maintenance – each section the responsibility of locals who had no resources for it. |
| 182-184 | Details of road improvements in Pisa in the 12th and 13th century. |
| 184-186 | Same for Florence in the 13th and 14th century. |
| 185 | Road inspections and administration. |
| 186 | Florence slower than Pisa to make improvements (perhaps due to the frequent changes in the administration). |
| 191 | Mercanzia would lobby the priors for road improvements – ran a ferry across the Elsa after the bridge destroyed – oversaw the activities of the vectuarii (carriers) in the contado. |
| 195 | Importance of the Arno for carrying goods – especially raw materials for textile industry – Tuscan industry dependent upon non-indigenous products. Signa (14 km downstream from Florence) the head of navigation. |
| 195 | Large barges (piatte) could go as far as Empoli. Goods transferred to scaffe (half the size) as far as Signa – only noccoli (1/10 the size of a scaffa) could go further upstream. |
| 196 | The transport of goods from Signa to Florence was the responsibility of the purchaser. |
| 196 | The problem of the stretch from Signa to Florence was not just that it was shallow but there was the problem of mills with fish weirs. |
| 196 | As well as the Arno route and the road in parallel, there was a larger road route Pisa-Lucca-Pistoia-Prato-Florence which was made passable for wagons before the riverside road. |
| 216 | Florentine efforts to make safe the northern route to Bologna. The new road over the Giogo pass became the preferred route from the Alps to Rome. New towns created such as Fiorenzuola (1322). Problems with the Ubaldini (1342-1377). |
| 219 | Six other castelli on other roads: two on the road to Faenza (anti-Guidi); three on the road to Arezzo (anti-Uberti). The Uberti/Pazzi/Tarlati sacked Figline in 1352; Consuma past towards the Casentino (Montalpruno). |
| 219 | Establishment of vicariates for suppression of brigandage. Raising of castles of rural nobility used for brigandage: Cavalcanti (two) and Gherardini (1302/1304) also Gangalandi castello at Lastra opposite Signa. From 1360s, problem of unemployed condottieri. |
| 222 | Florentine war with Pisa (taken 1406) and then with Genoa over Porto Pisano disrupted maritime trade – circuitous route for French/Catalan wool via Venice and then over the Apennines. Datini: Prato cloth to Spain and then Venice etc. other examples. |
| 225-226 | As the Florentine state expanded, it reduced the number of internal tolls, some owners bought out (including the Ubaldini). Tolls concentrated at frontiers allowing free passage throughout the state. |
| 228 | Manufacture of goods for long-distance trade was concentrated in only a few places: southern Netherlands, northern Italy and (from the 15th century) southern Germany. |
| 228-230 | The same powerhouses were also the locus for art (both cheap and expensive). |
| 231 | Much industry also in capital cities for local consumption by courts: London, Paris, Rome, Naples, Palermo. |
| 237 | The second great luxury cloth producing area (after the southern Netherlands) was Tuscany. Woollens dominated a number of cities (Siena, Prato, Pistoia, etc.) but key manufacturer was Florence. Villani claims that in the 1330s, 30,000 people out of 100,000 were engaged in the cloth industry. Note: the population of Florence equalled only by Venice, Milan, possibly Genoa. Was exceeded by Paris in Constantinople. According to Villani, Florence produced 80,000 rolls of cloth per annum for a value of 1.2 million florins – which equalled the combined income of the kings of France and England. |
| 238 | Luxury cloth was produced in Florence from the second quarter of the 14th century. Earlier they had been a greater quantity but of less quality from local sheep. |
| 238-239 | In the 13th century at the start of the 14th, Florence made cheap cloth that was widely traded (e.g. to Venice). Florentine merchant bought quality cloth in the southern Netherlands (initially via the Fairs of Champagne) for sale in Florence and southern Italy. The most expensive Florentine cloth was much cheaper than the cheapest cloth from the southern Netherlands. Florentine merchants already buying English wool and the collapse of the Flemish wool industry in the 1320s accelerated the process. Manufacture in Florence started as an invitation market of high quality South Netherlands cloth (panni alla francesca). Cloth workers from the southern Netherlands moved to Florence in sizeable numbers. |
| 239 | Luxury cloth made with English wool ceases to be seen as an imitation of southern Netherlands cloth. Cheaper cloth was made from Mediterranean wool. |
| 241 | The wool industry in Florence was controlled by the Arte del Lana (membership 200). They did not own the means of production but did own the material – subcontracting each of the many processes. |
| 241-248 | Description of wool processing. |
| 248 | Collapse in the production of luxury woollens in Florence and Tuscany in the 1340s. |
| 248 | Start century, Lucca was the dominant silk weaving city of Western Europe. Raw silk: a little produced locally in Lunigiana, imported from Sicily/Calabria or Asia Minor. Lucchese silk traded throughout Europe together with Middle Eastern and Chinese silk. |
| 248-249 | The different types of silk described. |
| 249 | Silk weaving more complex than due to patterning and use of different colours – dyeing had to be the thread and not the fabric. Gold/silver thread. |
| 250 | Some price comparisons (from purchases by English royalty in the first half of the 15th century): woollen scarlets 90s yard, damask/satins 13s4d/11s8d, velvets 30s. Skilled workmen were paid 6d a day so a yard of velvet was equivalent of 60 days work. |
| 250 | Second half of 13th century: workers from Lucca in other cities including one who invented a water-powered silk throwing machine. After 1314 [political upheavals] citizens fled to Florence and other Tuscan cities but also Bologna and Venice. The silk industry in Lucca declined thereafter. |
| 250 | In the 14th century silk industry in Lucca, Bologna, Venice but by the end of the 14th century, Florence began to make its presence felt. Workers from Lucca also in Milan and Genoa. Genoese and Venetians the principal importers of raw silk – but much (via Porto Pisano) for Bologna and Florence. |
| 250 | Great increase in Florentine silk production in the 1430s and 1440s. At this time the Medici invested in silk as well as wool. Silk partially replaced the declining wool industry but at the end of the 15th century it was still smaller. |
| 250-251 | Florentine: all podere dwellers to plant five mulberry bushes per year up to a maximum of 50. This president was followed elsewhere in northern Italy in the 15th century, France in the 16th, England in the 17th. Manufacturer of silk increase but still a lot from southern Italy and Asia Minor. |
| 272 | By the end of the 13th century, Florence, Pisa, Arezzo and Siena were producing primitive/derivative 'maiolica arciana'. |
| 275 | Florence: trade in cheap religious paintings – exported by Datini. |
| 275-276 | By the 15th century, Florence, Milan, Venice capital cities of prosperous states – site of conspicuous consumption and manufacture of luxury goods – local consumption but also export. |
| 279 | At the end of the 14th century, Florentine embroidery being sold from Avignon to Philippe the Bold. |
| 279 | Calimala ordered embroidered vestments and employed Antonio Pollaiuolo as designer. They also imported a team of embroiderers from Mechelen to make them (1466). |
| 282 | Florentine booksellers supplied England and the popes. The Vespiano da Bisticci had customers in England, Portugal and Hungary. |
| 284 | Northern Italy, including Florence, was the principal centre for printing books in the 15th century. |
| 286 | As the population grew in the 13th century, the standard of living for majority decline – became reliant on grain-based food. Population was at its peak in the first half of the 14th century. The population of the great cities was most vulnerable. Florence had an office to oversee the grain market and a special commission (Abbondanza) to manage the. Locally grown grain could only supply for five months, according to an official of the Abbondanza, Domenico Lenzi. |
| 288 | The shortfall was made up by imports via Pisa – South and Sicily, Black Sea. Devastating famine in 1330. |
| 288-291 | To normally separate grain markets: Northern Europe and southern Europe. But, in times of famine, it was profitable to trade north to south or vice versa. |
| 291 | A store, built over the Orsanmichele was built to provide a grain reserve. |
| 293 | Wine grown extensively in northern Italy but not enough to meet local demand (with the exception of Liguria). The Genoese imported wines from southern Italy via Pisa. |
| 303 | Some olive oil produced in Tuscany but not enough. Main source southern Italy. |
| 316 | By the end of the Middle Ages, mulberry trees still no further north than Tuscany. |
| 320 | Florentine brick kilns at Greve, 10 km south of the city – i.e. close to it. |
| 327 | English wool exported to Flanders at least from 1113. In the 12th and the first half the 13th centuries, Flemings were great purchasers of English wool. But during the 13th century, Italians eased them out is able to offer better terms to sellers/producers. Initially, this wall was sent to Flanders but early in the 14th century, Italians started shipping it directly to Italy and trade came into the hands of bankers such as the Bardi and the Peruzzi. In 1305, 45,000 sacks. Each sack represented the wool from between 180 and 250 sheep. |
| 328 | The bankruptcies of the Florentine banks meant that the English export trade was taken over by English merchants. Affected by an export tax per sack which hit lower quality wool. As a result, the southern Netherlands industry more and more concentrated on luxury cloth. |
| 329 | The only rival to English wool came from Castile or Leon. |
| 330 | Initially, Spanish wool was only good for cheap cloth but, on an initiative of Pedro IV (1336-84), the importation of merino sheep from North Africa and crossbreeding made it as good as the English. |
| 331 | Castilian wall was able to supplant English wall in Flanders due to fiscal policies. Castilian wool also exported to Italy via Cordoba. |
| 342 | West of a line Antwerp-Nuremberg-Venice, most payments were made by bill of exchange; east of that line all made by bullion (gold or silver). Overall imbalances in the West also settled by bullion. |
| 343-344 | Judging imbalances is difficult but some trends discernible – e.g. North Italian ports and those of the eastern Mediterranean and Black Sea. |
| 346 | The table on this page shows a bullion imbalance of 330,000 ducats out of the total trade of 660,000 in the 15th century... |
| 347 | … in trade with the Levant and further east. |
| 347 | The 14th century, the imbalance was even greater. |
| 348 | Ever more bullion to the eastern Mediterranean – Asia Minor and Greece, etc. largest expenditure was for alum. |
| 348 | The Baltic trade was also unbalanced. |
| 348 | Inflow of precious metal into Europe only came from North Africa. |
| 349 | Terms of trade between North Africa and Europe was in favour of the latter. |
| 350-351 | The southern Netherlands and northern Italy were able to retain large quantities of bullion due to the balance of trade in their favour (raw materials in, finished goods out). In Tuscany/Lombardy, also profit from services such as banking and shipping. |
| 351 | Trade imbalance in favour of northern Italy as opposed to north-west Europe… |
| 351-352 | … exacerbated when Italians began making their own 'Flemish' woollens. |
| 362 | In most places, miners owned their minds but in Italy (Tuscany) investment and mining by non-miners began early (beginning of the 13th century). Not replicated north of the Alps until the 15th century. |
| 389 | The first 20 years of the 15th century were regarded in Florence as a period of unprecedented prosperity – but nobody could remember the situation of a hundred years earlier. |
| Page | Note |
![]()