Notes: Tabacco The Struggle for Power
Source: Tabacco,G., The Struggle for Power in Mediaeval Italy: Structures of Political Rule (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1989)
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Page | Note |
|---|---|
| 46 | The army increasingly recruited from German sources both within and outside of the Empire. |
| 47 | Also, increasingly Germans were placed in higher ranks and ultimately the Senate. |
| 48 | The above already taking place in the fourth century. |
| 49 | The barbarian population within the cat Empire was allowed to keep its own politico-military structures (foederati). |
| 49 | Honorius was the first Emperor of the West (son of Theodosius the Great). |
| 50 | By contrast, in the East Germans were kept away from 'home rule' and high command. |
| 51 | Galla Placidia's son Valentinian III was installed by a Byzantine army with the aim of limiting Germanic influence in the West. |
| 51 | In the West, the Germanic influence won out over the Byzantines: Odoacer and Theodoric. |
| 52 | Ricimer the power behind the throne for several short lived Western emperors. |
| 52-53 | Odoacer deposed Romulus Augustulus in 476 and then ran a military dictatorship for 13 years. |
| 53 | Odoacer recognised the Eastern Emperor and her general support in Italy from both civil and military. |
| 53 | Vandals held North Africa/Sardinia/Corsica but returned Sicily. |
| 53 | Formal acceptance of Byzantine supremacy over the confluence of Germanic military and Romano-Italic bureaucracy. |
| 53-54 | Odoacer's rule was a period of stability – there was no emperor with competing claims. |
| 54 | 445: Valentinian III granted papal authority to Pope Leo the Great. |
| 55 | Odoacer's supporters came from different Germanic groups so there was no racial cohesion. |
| 56 | Odoacer preserved the traditional political/administrative apparatus. |
| 59 | 489-493: Ostrogoths and other Germanic tribes invade Italy and end Odoacer's regime. |
| 59 | 533-534: Byzantine forces destroyed the vandal regime in North Africa – just before they attacked the ostrogoth kingdom in Italy. |
| 60 | Theodoric had changeable relations with the Byzantine Empire. At times was recognised as 'magister militum'. |
| 60 | Theodoric's regime had the same Roman/Germanic appearance as Odoacer's. Theodoric arrived in Italy with the approval of the Empire and titles which Odoacer never had. |
| 60-61 | Theodoric's supreme authority over all Italy was accepted but his title was less than 'Emperor'. |
| 61 | Theodoric was accepted because he fitted in with the Roman traditions and practices. |
| 62 | Long period of peace due to the symbiotic relationship of the Ostrogoths with the old Roman elites and Church leaders (even if Theodoric himself was an Arian). |
| 68 | This symbiosis did not survive Theodoric's death and coincided with the arrival of Justinian determined to restore the Empire. 20 years of war with large scale depredations. |
| 69 | The sophistication of the Ostrogoths defence, both political and military, as well as Byzantine intransigence prolonged the war and paved the way for the Lombards. |
| 70 | Breakdown of the symbiosis; the Roman elites now anti-Goth. |
| 71 | 554: Gothic resistance ceases and the Emperor installs a new administrative regime in Italy. |
| 71 | Great bond between the landowning elites in Italy and the Imperial court. Suppression of Arianism. |
| 72 | New regime was centralised around Constantinople and not Rome with Ravenna as a military headquarters even after the end of the war. |
| 74 | 569: Lombards already at Milan. |
| 74 | The Lombards had served the Byzantine Empire in the last stages of the Gothic war but were so violent that they were let go. |
| 74 | The Lombards were alien to Roman influence and culture. |
| 75 | The Lombards had no set plan of conquest. They occupy the Apennines and hinder Byzantine movement between Rome and Ravenna – these remained in Byzantine hands for more than 150 years. |
| 75 | Situation was generally very fluid and confused – the Lombards were without a king from 574-584; their territories were controlled by local military leaders. |
| 76 | The general confusion and fragmentation with unique and unprecedented in the former Roman Empire. |
| 76 | The Byzantine Empire was able to hold the coast as they had command of the sea (until the arrival of the Arabs). |
| 76-77 | Details of Byzantine held territory – autonomous blocks. |
| 77 | Within the Byzantine Empire civil administration merged into military. |
| 78 | Italy was fragmented whereas (say) Gaul was not in the elite class in Gaul remained intact. |
| 79 | In Gaul, social hegemonies merged – i.e. the Frankish with the Gallo-Roman. |
| 79 | Byzantine presence in the seventh century: Exarchate of Ravenna, Duchy of Rome linked by road running through Perugia. |
| 79 | Ravenna had strong maritime links with Constantinople; many Greeks in the population. |
| 80 | In Italy, the Byzantine armies were now on the defensive and were recruited locally; Constantinople had too many other commitments to be able to reinforce them. |
| 82 | In the Exarchate, strong regional feeling – dense networks of economic/ecclesiastical interests centring around Metropolitan Bishop of Ravenna. |
| 83 | Similarly with the Duchy of Rome – Patrimony of St Peter (beginning of the idea of a Papal State). |
| 85 | By the eighth century, local forces around the pope were effectively resisting the Lombards and replacing Byzantine rule (without formally acknowledging it). Negotiations with the Franks: Pope Zacharias (741-752). |
| 86 | Links with the Franks resisted by the Archbishop of Ravenna; alarm when Frankish gains from Lombards given to Rome alone – not to the official Byzantine administration. |
| 86 | 774: collapse of the Lombard regime. In former Byzantine areas the Franco – Roman view prevailed. Although the archbishop of Ravenna hung on, the influence of Constantinople declined in the Exarchate. |
| 86 | Frank's role the North and Rome but the Byzantine Duchy of Naples and the Lombard Duchy of Benevento continue to exist, the latter having survived the collapse of the Lombard kingdom. |
| 88 | Although nominally Byzantine, the civil administration in Rome was gradually subsumed under papal authority. |
| 89 | In the 760s, the Duke and Bishop of Naples came from the same family. |
| 89 | Military forces in Naples were under the command of the strategos of Sicily. |
| 89 | End of the seventh century/beginning of the eighth, creation of the Theme of Sicily consisting of the island and southern Italy as a bulwark against the Arabs now occupying Carthage and North Africa. |
| 90 | Military requirements created the need for the consolidation of areas previously separate: Sicily, Naples, Calabria – Southern Byzantine Italy was centred on Syracuse and not Ravenna. That said, Naples was too far from Syracuse. |
| 90 | The Pope rebels against Leo III over the iconoclasm controversy. As a result, Sicily/Calabria were transferred from the patriarch of Rome to the patriarch of Constantinople. |
| 90 | First Arab attacks on Sicily at the end of the seventh century and the first half of the eighth. |
| 91 | Sicily alone loyal to Byzantium – Sardinia attacked by the Arabs; Corsica overrun by the Lombards and then the Franks. |
| 91 | Lombard Italy: social system of landowners and military/political class – i.e. like Byzantine Italy. |
| 93 | In the eighth century, authority was maintained by an armed class sustained by landed property integrated into the regional environment. |
| 94 | The Lombard polity was transformed and sophisticated by a process of osmosis with neighbouring Rome. |
| 100-102 | The Catholic clergy were used to operating with the organised Roman administration and gradually took over from the more casual transient arrangements of the Lombards. |
| 102 | Helped by the authoritarian outlook of leaders who thought of themselves as Roman emperors. |
| 103 | The ability of Pavia to control Spoleto and Benevento was limited (especially by the presence of Byzantine territory between). |
| 103 | Problems of span of control affected both Lombard and Byzantine areas strong centrifugal tendencies/fragmentation. |
| 111 | Despite their having been 'civilised', the papacy continued to dislike the Lombards and encouraged the Franks to intervene in order to protect the 'Apostolic See', the Lombards were still seen as alien and not Roman. |
| 111 | The Lombards were encroaching on Ravenna and the Roman duchy lands with the aim of removing the Byzantine barrier between northern and southern Lombard territory. |
| 112 | 750: the Lombards occupy the Exarchate. |
| 112-113 | 774: Pope Hadrian I and Charlemagne – The Franks to have the extreme north and north-west and everything else north of the future Regno to be Papal. |
| 113 | 773: Spoleto Lombards desert the Pavia kingdom for the Pope. |
| 114 | Tensions within the Duchy of Rome. 800: Charlemagne crowned Emperor recognition of the fact of Frankish power over non-Byzantine Italy. |
| 115 | Pope still had political domination – but under Frankish hegemony. |
| 115 | Franks imported the military administration over all their territories. |
| 115 | Frankish domination can be seen as a continuation of the Pavia kingdom: Italia = regnum Longobardorum. There was a Carolingian king but not the same one as north of the Alps. Only the Frankish king who ruled Italy had the imperial title. |
| 116 | Spoleto had Frankish dukes after the death of Hildebrand but Benevento remained separate. |
| 116 | The Frankish settlement was not mass migration but the insertion of small military groups. |
| 116 | Istria taken from the Byzantine Empire after the fall of the Lombard kingdom. |
| 117 | Some Lombard accounts were incorporated into the Frankish kingdom but these were gradually replaced when the line fell vacant. |
| 124 | At the end of the ninth century, the Carolingian Empire dissolved into separate kingdoms – each kingdom (including Italy) also dissolved. Great tendency towards autonomy. Ultimately there was political anarchy in the pre-communal/communal periods. |
| 124 | The leaders of the kingdom, both lay and ecclesiastical, initiated royal vassalage and created client networks based on themselves. |
| 128 | 888: death of Charles the Fat – the last Carolingian to have all territories in his hand. |
| 128 | Ecclesiastical immunity led to prelates having the same powers in their territories as counts and gave them autonomous power. |
| 130 | Clienteles of counts, dude, marquesses were increasingly on a personal basis and not on the basis of the office – loosening the connections with the royal power. |
| 135 | Rulers were unable to create a bureaucracy of easily removable royal agents. Rewards to royal officials in land which increased the landed based of the military. |
| 136 | Spoleto was ultimately linked to Frankish power. Benevento retained Lombard rulers determined to maintain local autonomy. |
| 137 | Benevento occasionally played tribute to the Franks and acknowledged Frankish supremacy but it retained local autonomy. In any event the basic political model the same as in Frankish lands. |
| 138 | Benevento was subject to the same centrifugal pressures and secessions, e.g. Salerno seceded from Benevento and Kath were seceded from Salerno. |
| 139 | Extreme fragmentation came earlier and Benevento than elsewhere due to external pressures: Arabs, Franks, Roman Church, Byzantine Empire. Led to local Lombards looking for allies outside the Duchy to gain advantage inside. |
| 139 | Arab attacks based on Tunis. |
| 139 | Byzantine naval resistance to Arabs centred on Syracuse. |
| 140 | Sicily was the target for Arab assaults from the early ninth century. Palermo the centre of Arab power in Sicily. Minor settlements also in Apulia and Campania. |
| 140 | Duke of Naples brought Arabs to Campania in order to counter the threat from Benevento. |
| 140 | Arabs also used by Lombard princes in their own internal struggles. |
| 140 | Bari was an Arab emirate for 20 years until 871. |
| 140 | No real penetration of Arabs into the regional power base in mainland Italy... |
| 141 | ... as opposed to Sicily where an Arab based polity gradually asserted itself. |
| 141 | Attempts at alliances between the Franks and the Byzantine Empire to repel the Arabs were ineffective as both were interested in controlling Italy. |
| 141 | The anti-Arab offensive of Basil I (867-86). |
| 142 | Basil able to capture Bari and drew the Lombards of Benevento into his sphere of influence as they distrusted the Franks. Arabs ejected from Taranto and two Byzantine themes created: Longobardia and Calabria. Campania remained outside. The Duchy of Naples had gradually disintegrated into the nominally Byzantine cities of Gaeta, Naples and Amalfi. The Byzantine resurgence coincided with the decline of the Carolingian Empire. |
| 143 | Between the Frankish and Byzantine areas of influence a sort of no man's land existed. |
| 152 | After the death of Charles the Fat (888), the Empire and the kingdom of Italy were contested by well-established Frankish military families using strong patronage networks and their immense landholdings. Berengar of Friuli and Guy of Spoleto, both border duchies originally Royal appointments but had become hereditary. The nature of the counties was ambiguous they were both royal districts but also centres of private power. |
| 152-153 | After 898, legislative activity stopped [indicator of breakdown of central authority?] |
| 154 | Berengar survived until 924. |
| 154-155 | Berengar's diplomas granted rights to a variety of people and institutions. He supported autonomy, especially bishops and castles. |
| 155 | From the beginning of the 10th century, public order was being undermined – exemptions impoverish the exchequer, alienation of sites and military and judicial power. Many communities. |
| 156 | The Kingdom [of Italy] accepted and promoted autonomy. Public power unable to provide local protection – instability of the throne plus Magyar incursions (898 – mid 10th century). |
| 156 | Counts/marquesses were too busy protecting their own territories to protect towns and cities. Failure of the the kings led to aristocratic revolts. Failures of local magnates led to local groups, religious communities, cities represented by bishops to set up their own defences (incastellamento) which tended to be set in perpetuity. |
| 158 | The Crown accepted these tendencies hoping that the groups would attach themselves to the Crown. Donations of full property rights and land. |
| 158 | Alienation is continued throughout the 10th and 11th centuries; similar things happened north of the Alps. |
| 159 | Further disintegration due to distribution of inheritance to heirs [partible inheritance]. |
| 160 | Between the 10th and 12th centuries, any element of a territorial power could be disposed of ad libitum |
| 162 | The Canossas: originally from Lucca, circa 940 given land around Parma by Hugh [of Provence], relationship with higher power was purely political, not economic; given control of counties and bishoprics in the area. Beginnings of a dynasty that in the 11th century controlled:Brescia, Mantua, Reggio, Modena, Ferrara and the March of Tuscany. |
| 163 | Canossa territory was allodial – adding to the breaking up of royal authority as the Canossas' power derived from their own patronage network and not royal authority. They were given titles to keep them loyal but this also enhanced their own authority. |
| 164 | Royal/imperial authority maintained despite local initiatives but increasingly just 'generic hegemony' as it could not guarantee security. That said, it could intervene to strengthen or disrupt other centres of power. Others sought recognition from the Crown but checked its interference. |
| 164 | The Crown was elective and not hereditary [therefore lessened its power]. |
| 165 | Otto I intervenes in 951 – compounds the existing situation. |
| 165 | Otto did not seek election to the Kingdom of Italy [but took it for himself]. |
| 165 | German military might meant that Otto and his successors had overlordship but this did not affect the fragmentation of power described earlier. |
| 165 | Otto crowned Emperor in 962. |
| 165 | At the beginning of the 11th century, the extinction of the Ottonian line. Attempts in Italy to cut ties to Germany failed |
| 166 | German pomp could not disguise the disintegration of public power, especially the appropriation of power by the ecclesiastical authorities which began in the early 10th century. |
| 167 | Allodial churches could be very powerful politically and militarily – equal in power to lay authority. |
| 169 | The concept of private property gave power over others and allowed greater autonomy; broke up any ordered political system. |
| 169 | Bishoprics and cathedral chapters were not part of the Royal patrimony but the king claimed authority over them and made appointments which suited him. For example, in Tuscany where there was a succession of bishops of origin foreign to the diocese alternating with local appointments from the military aristocracy or leading citizens of the episcopal city. |
| 170 | Bishops, even outsiders, appointed by the King tended to go native, joining with other clerics as an alternative authority in opposition to the King. Royal appointments strengthened local autonomy as canon law prevented the king from interfering. Royal control was intermittent (long absences of the German Kings from Italy). Dubious legality due to the separation of regnum and sacerdotium. |
| 171 | In the 10th/11th centuries, the movement for ecclesiastical reform revealed the threadbare nature of royal authority over the Church, culminating in Canossa 1077. |
| 171 | In 11th century, reformers attacked lay control over churches and advocated papal claims to supremacy over the kingdom and empire. |
| 172 | Tendency for bishops to assume temporal responsibilities in cities which were their seats. However bishops did tend to represent the interests of all citizens, especially the leading ones... |
| 173 | ... At a time when leading citizens had no organisation of their own. |
| 173 | Cities grew in economic importance and made themselves independent of the count's authority. For example in Milan, the Archbishop not been ceded jurisdiction over the city by the king but de facto had it through his own system of patronage (vassalagw with local elites – from the last decades of the 10th century. The Archbishop granted benefices in the contado to elites. |
| 174 | In general, bishops did not take on the rank of count but shared control with a plurality of lay and clerical elites. General lack of coordinated authority over the territory, nominally under the control the count. |
| 174 | Papal exception. Although not always successful, popes retain control over the Roman Duchy and laid claims to Ravenna and the Pentapolis. |
| 175 | In 11th century, a three-way tussle between popes, emperor and local aristocracy but ecclesiastical reform gave the popes the edge over both the others. |
| 175-176 | Success of the reform movement increased papal hopes for a theocracy but drove lay groups to seek a similar rational basis of authority of their own. |
| 176 | Papal moves also improved the situation of the Byzantine Empire in southern Italy. In the first half of the 10th century, both popes and the kingdom looked for greater ties with Constantinople. |
| 177 | Byzantine aims were thwarted by the consolidation of the remaining Lombard Holdings in southern Italy into Capua-Benevento. The second half of the 10th century, conflict between the Empire and the Lombards, helped by the Ottonian emperors). |
| 178 | Towards the end of the 10th century, Capua-Benevento collapsed and Ottonian intervention in the south failed. Major Saracen attacks while Constantinople was occupied in the East. Byzantine holdings in Italy were left to their own devices and started to develop local autonomies as in the North. |
| 179 | The Normans, originally hired as mercenaries by all sides, gradually impose themselves in the whole of southern Italy (including Sicily) and created an effective kingdom that was recognised as such by the popes in 1130. |
| 181 | The papacy saw the Normans as a tool against the Byzantine Empire and therefore encouraged them, especially as they recognised the papacy as their spiritual overlord. |
| 185-186 | End of the 10th century: emergence of 'collegiate magistracy' – bodies of leading citizens representing the interests of all citizens which gradually became 'communes'. Consuls gradually replace the lords of the cities especially where clerics were drawn into the papal orbit. |
| 187 | Emergence of wealthy merchant class who were not 'milites'. [The whole process of commune formation seems to have been driven by social forces – military/mercantile elites combining to reduce the influence of lords (lay or clerical).] |
| 188 | Extinction of the comital dynasty with the death of Matilda 1115. |
| 190 | The consulate was a permanent magistracy of the city sustained by the consensus of popular assemblies and legal opinions – the latter providing an institutional framework. |
| 217 | Barbarossa's concessions at Constance were for the Lombard League only. Elsewhere (Tuscany) he replaced local forces with direct imperial appointments. |
| 219 | In seeking to take control of their contado, cities used the ecclesiastical boundaries of their bishop or the old comital boundaries, whichever was larger. |
| 220 | Sacrum imperium' was a term to claim authority over the whole of the kingdom but in practice, it lacked a centre of gravity and neither economic support or social base.The emperor was only able to exercise authority when present and, even then, was 'a useless and costly complication' to the ongoing political conflict. Papal authority was a point of appeal for opponents of the emperor. |
| 221 | Conflicting claims: sacrum imperium versus papal claims for the supremacy of the priesthood (see Investiture Crisis). |
| 222 | Cities' power was not a theoretical construct in the same way as that of the Empire or the Papacy but a natural centre of attraction of economic activities, patriarchal interests, seigneurial and ecclesiastical ambitions and demographic growth. Also an epicentre for inter-factional and class conflicts. |
| 222 | Population growth (immigration) a complicating factor in the operation of the urban institutional framework. |
| 223 | Too free the communes from the vestiges of episcopal/comital power took more than a hundred years. |
| 224 | Podestà were a means for achieving urban unity but the effect was offset by the strengthening of consorterie and the agreements that they made with each other. |
| 225 | Symbiotic relationship between milites and the upper commercial classes. |
| 227 | Growth and organisation of the popolo as a counterweight to the nobility. |
| 230 | Factions in one city made alliances with factions in rival cities using convenient frameworks (e.g. Guelph/Ghibelline. Exiled factions also used allies in their own contado. |
| 231 | Complexity of internal conflicts – class, inter-and intra-guild rivalries, rivalry between quarters of the same city. Continuing strain however was the 'gradi' versus the 'populani'. |
| 234 | Major members of the Calimala guild were designated as magnates between 1293-1295. |
| 248 | Mid-14th century: domination of the Bardi, Peruzzi and Acciaiuoli in Mezzogiorno finance. |
| 256-257 | The Guelph-Ghibelline dispute was not just about the conflict between Church and Empire but was a mass of conflicting interests as well. The Empire disappeared as a serious player after the death of Frederick II but the parties actually became more fixed in their views. Major role played by the Pope. |
| 258 | After the death of Frederick II, parties were still defined by being pro-or anti-Papacy. Manfred was an effective anti-papal leader until the Battle of Benevento. The combined territory of Sicily and Naples was at the disposal of the Pope until the Sicilian Vespers. Palermo and Naples were then the basis for rivalry. Local disputes were labelled Guelph/Ghibelline in order to provide greater justification. For example, Florence in the 1230s/1240s. Both parties allied with the growing in importance popolo . Overlapping institutions between commune/popolo and Guelphs/Ghibellines. |
| 261 | Guelfism.came to be associated with the strengthening of the institution of the popolo. |
| 261 | The conjunction of popolo/Guelph first appeared in Florence in the 1250s and 60s and was a reaction to the earlier excesses of imperial agents in the city. |
| 263-264 | War in 1312 as Florence and the Angevins tried to strength city against Ghibelline reinforcements (presence of Henry VII in Lombardy). |
| 268-287 | Long section on state formation in Florence. |
| Page | Note |
![]()