Notes: Faini Firenze nell’età romanica
Source: Faini, E., Firenze nell’età romanica (1000-1211) (Florence: Olschki, 2010)
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Note |
|---|
| Chapter I: Birth of a Civic Identity – Sources for the 10th to 13th Centuries |
| Discontinuities of sources – before a certain date, lack of knowledge of shared past, civic identity – only takes hold in full in the 12th century. |
| Stories of the past to excess but all the data comes from the 13th-14th centuries. There are few traces of civic pride [author gives examples]. |
| From the ninth century onwards, Florence begins to be important – trade arrival to Lucca – residents for local aristocrats (Godfrey of Lorraine and Beatrice). |
| Godfrey of Lorraine's brother, Pope Stephen IX, died in Florence and was buried in Santa Reparata. |
| However, there was no written history until the end of the 12th century. |
| Florentines help Giovanni Gualberto in his struggles with Bishop Atto– founding of the monastery of Valombrosa (late 11th century) not recorded any Florentine chronicle. |
| The first real Florentine chronicle worthy of the name was the Gesta Florentinorum(1230s). |
| Sanzanome and others say that at the end of the 11th or beginning of the 12th century, Florence began to be an important autonomous military power but they are not precise in what they mean. |
| Sources tend to disagree about events. The first event in which they agree was the destruction of Montebuoni (1135). |
| A large part of the communal archive was lost during the removal of Walter de Brienne in 1343. This is the first real recognition of Florence as an institution – transferred into the communal registered 1216. Sporadic entries but less so after the 1170s. |
| The sparse quantity or absence of written records requires reliance on oral accounts which were written down. Need to know how the people concerned knew as well as what they knew. |
| 23rd May 1203:26 witness statements regarding a border dispute between Florence and Siena over Poggibonsi from local lords or their staff. Some describe the interaction of civil authorities (e.g. podestà or consuls) in describing the events of 1176. No one remembered any civic interaction or document older than 40 years (from 1203). |
| In the south of Florentine territory, nobody can put a face to civic authority before the second half of the 12th century; matters improve little at the start of the 13th century. |
| Case study dispute between the nuns of Santa Maria di Rosano with the Guidi counts; in 1204 the widow releases the convent from its obligations. |
| Some witnesses remember events of 1157; the same problem of identifying the faces of civic power prior to the 1170s. |
| 1176: the peace agreement between Florence and Siena mentions the names of Florentine consuls for the first time in relation to the Rosano statement. |
| What happened in Florentine territory prior to the last 30 years in the 12th century is unclear but afterwards the relationship between city and contado are more dynamic and precise. Witness statements for the city are similar – names begin to be known in the business of politics is discernible. |
| At the dawn of the 13th century many relevant documents regarding the city are in non-urban monasteries (e.g.Vallombrosa). [Check ASI CLXVII (2009) p. 3-55] |
| Chapter II: The Land |
| Agriculture - the relationship between town and contado - social relationships in the contado. |
| Chapter III: Society: The Turning Point of the Twelth Century |
| Florentine history is more noted for internal strife than victories over external enemies. During Florence's uncertain rise to power, contemporaries painted a picture of a united city; things weren't as bad as the conflicts of Dante's time but the city was not peaceful nor united. |
| Community strife was often behind the many fires that regularly consumed parts of the city (quotes from Villani) |
| At the start of the 12th century, Florence was a young society – many recent immigrants – driving a reorganisation of the hierarchy and social roles. Difficult to reconstruct when so little is known – have to suppose that these roles were driven by the existing faultlines in society. |
| There is no trace of the term 'civis' before the first third of the 12th century but the term 'civitas' was used in the 11th century. Use of 'civis' only begins in the 1170s, as does the terms 'commune' (originally as an adjective or adverb'. Decline in the use of the term 'civitas' – in 1187, Henry VI talks of 'nostorum civium Florentinorum'. |
| 1184: use of 'districtus' (i.e. city and contado). Use of 'populus'rather than 'cives' did not apply to all inhabitants – a social distinction not a geographical one. |
| The composition of society changed greatly around the turn of the 11th-12th centuries – no indication of which groups or individuals dominated. Church documents not enough to use as basis for the search – use, where possible, family records. Faini picked 222 families, mostly on the basis that at least one member is named in communal documents prior to 1211. |
| Even with this sample, the data is very patchy – only 13% can be examined over a period of a century. |
| Identification of Florentine elites in the 11th century is difficult as they moved from town to country (back and forth) with ease. This stopped in the second quarter of the 12th century |
| There are always problems with scant documentation; Faini stresses the peripatetic lifestyle of the Florentine elites and gives examples. Largely caused by the movements of the courts of the marquis, count or bishops. |
| City was the privileged location for the exercise of public power (especially tribunals). |
| The middle of the 12th century marks the largest separation (for several decades) of town and country – the upper classes stopped moving – but evidence still scanty. |
| The beginning of the 12th century marked the end of the Canossa dynasty [Matilda died in 1115]. This had a knock-on effect politically – the key element in the separation of town and country – end of the placituri. |
| The only family found regularly in both town and country was the Visdomini due to their role as episcopal administrators. [Faini is basing his conclusions by comparing names in legal and other documents]. |
| The phenomenon only began to change in the 1170s, often on official communal business showing the renewed contact between the city authorities and the contado. The same phenomenon can be observed for judges and legal experts as for aristocrats. |
| At the end of the 12th/beginning of the 13th centuries, noble families began to (re-)appear in the city – probably to deal with legal problems. |
| 12th century also was the period in which noble families tended to become identified with a certain place; they still moved around but had fixed roots. This can be shown by the increased use of names using geographical location as well as name and patronymic, usually linked with the locus of local power. Only when the use of geographical names spread down the social ladder did it come to refer to the provenance of people rather than where they held power. The same can be observed in city documents. |
| The end of the 11th century marked the split between city and country dwellers. The first were territorial lords, the second were those from whom the first communal leaders were drawn. Release from obligations to a central power (marquis, bishop) the lords retreated to their power bases in the country. Together with the growing population, the presence of these lords led to a movement into the city – especially those within 15 km of the city (they could still control their rural holdings) – but the balance was in favour of exit rather than entry. At the onset of Florentine economic growth, it wasn't lords wanting to invest their disposable income but immigrants cut off from their roots leading to survive by investing in nonagricultural activities. These activities are not known but were probably the cloth industry and trade. This movement also coincided with much urban development by lords in the country (new towns) – together with a tendency within the city for 'districtisation' (people with the same rural origins and collective identity living in close proximity to each other). |
| At the end of the 12th / start of the 13th century, the commune enforced on rural lords the obligation to spend part of their time in the city but urban residents could also have been for financial or prestige reasons – Florence was seen as the place to be. |
| Feudal ties were mainly outside the city but the biggest feudal overlord was the bishop. |
| The population revolted against the Bishop (1230 – 1240), local aristocrats also rejected the episcopal podestà. |
| Before 1150 towers were not mentioned much documents – often for particular reasons. Usually linked with the names of Florentine highest nobility (mid 12th century). According to G. Villani, in 1177 there was unprecedented violence in the city due to the construction of new towers. |
| According to the Annales Fiorentini II, in 1177/8 there was war between the consuls and the Ubiati . The city was burnt and the bridge collapsed (possibly due to flood). |
| Fighting seems to have died down in the 1180s. Various real estate documents as indicators of pacts of alliance (or at least nonaggression) but very few agreements as such. |
| A document of 1180 indicates that communal authorities were interested in limiting the size and extent of towers and walls. |
| Agreement of 1209 makes clear reference to the communal ban on new towers – and, by implication, the end of warlike groups. Development of arbitration agreements for dispute resolution named officers to run the towers. |
| Agreements could have economic clauses as well as military ones. Towers could have workshops 'rented out' – towers and the groups that own them were not exclusively military. |
| In 1178/9, there was an agreement concerning the business alliance rather than a military one. |
| Those concerned with these pacts included communal officials and those from high society but also those with less prestigious backgrounds. |
| Towers served to cement internal relationships – height was used as a symbol of influence. 'Tower society' was for the highest ranks of society but did include families of the second rank. |
| There was a nucleus of people and families who could assume political roles. |
| The end of the 12th century, the first contract appear mentioning credit. Lending to further religious activities was much used by the upper classes in the 12th century – not only the urban nobility but rural as well. |
| Religious bodies were used as a liquidity reserve. Urban loans tended to be solely money, rural ones use possessions as collateral. This does not mean that the contado was short of liquidity – the advances came from rural religious bodies, not urban ones. |
| After the middle of the 12th century, credit relations began to involve groups of people rather than one-on-one. |
| At the beginning of the 13th century, urban aristocrats began to get hold of patrimony owned by religious bodies by foreclosing on debts. |
| From the end of the 12th century, collectivities begin to appear which are not family related but associations of non-relatives (only in the city). |
| Until the mid 12th century, it is not possible to see a distinction between urban and rural aristocracy – in pre-communal era, the same names appear in both town and country. |
| A split between rural and urban society can be seen from the onset of the 12th century – aristocratic 'commuting' stopped quite suddenly – the effect of the end of the Canossa dynasty (1115). |
| Chapter IV: Political and Institutional Dynamics |
| Bordone: Throughout the Middle Ages, Italian cities were aware of the difference with respect to the countryside. It is not certain when they created a separate political identity – acting autonomously – making decisions about war and peace. Historians now downplay the notion of a 'pre-communal age' as some cities (Milan, Pisa, and others) were already organised and took autonomous initiatives even in the 11th century. It is not possible to consider the nature of these regimes to be the same as that of the 12th century. The nature of political representation in the 11th/12th centuries is very difficult to determine. 'Separatists' regard the first appearance of consuls as the changing point. 'Continuity' note the role of bishops in the transition from Carolingian rule to communal role per se. Episcopal rule is considered to be: |
| a) the immediate precursor of the commune or |
| b) its direct opponent. |
| Since 'representation' in the political sense means performing civic duties on behalf of others – we have to ask to what degree did the representatives have power to make decisions which involve the mass population. |
| For Florence, surviving documentation does not shed any light on this.Does this absence means that there was no representational merely an unchanging one? |
| It is necessary to look elsewhere, specifically at least two Tuscan sits by the mid-12th century had complex institutions with Britain rules: Pisa (1162 and 1164 documents) and destroyer (1140 – 1180). More details in the text. |
| Both show much use of indirect election: the consuls chosen by the electorate and all other officials chosen by the consuls. The Camino question of the electorate getting to choose everybody. It is legitimate to speak of communal democracy but a very different form of it from direct democracy.Not so much the greatest possible collective participation as the fragmentation of choice and setting of choice by others. |
| There was a general assembly of citizens to whom the officials were accountable but this did not meet often. |
| In the early communes, representatives represented groups rather than individuals – these groups' memberships were also elected on similar principles. |
| Najemy: 'late communal Florence was a sovereign federation of equal and autonomous guilds' (Corporatism & Consensus). This is not the same the earlier period but it was recognised that there were distinct, different, bodies within the polity. |
| In the 1130s in both Siena and Florence rural lords submitted themselves to the bishops and communal authorities. |
| The Episcopate played a major role in the definition of the urban community but the exact relationship between lay and ecclesiastical men is complicated and difficult to unravel. It is possible to say that lay involvement in the episcopal administration was the first example of lay involvement in the administration of the countryside (e.g. the activities of the Visdomini and the Tosinghi)but all of this was not yet institutionalised but dependent upon individual circumstances. |
| The origins of episcopal authority over lay matters is shrouded in mystery. For example, there is no document from the emperors giving them such authority, other than one from 874 – 5. Such documentation that exists refers to the countryside and not the city per se. But there is a reasonable amount of evidence that up to 1080, the bishops were extending their influence over the countryside via 'feudal' links. |
| The episcopate of Ildebrando (1008 – 1024) reveals the first signs of political collaboration between Bishop and Lehman – but it was limited (Ildebrando deferred to the Emperor). The same period has the first lay involvement in the management of Episcopal affairs (Davizzo omnipresent).Also the involvement of Ildebrando in trade. |
| Mozzabarba quarrels with the city and aligns himself with the rural nobility [is this correct? Check Dameron]. |
| Goffredo (1114 – 1142) was an interventionist bishop pursuing different policies to that of his predecessor Ranieri (1071 – 1113). Ranieri was a staunch supporter of Matilda against the Emperor but had no interest in political domination of the city.Goffredo was against Matilda as Canossa power waned and allied himself with the city where he had many followers. There was also an alliance between the urban and rural aristocracy. |
| In documenting the capture of Fiesole in 1125,Sanzanome (Gesta Florentinorum) mentions for the first time the existence of consoles in Florence – possibly with the blessing of Goffredo - suggesting a high degree of autonomy but also a means for Goffredo to influence urban affairs. |
| At the end of the 1120s, the city broke away from the Goffredo line (he was doing business with the Marquis Conrad – some intra-city conflicts which involved the marquis. |
| Tension between episcopal power based in the countryside but who was also head of the city exploded dramatically in the 1130s. Florence was denied privileges granted to other cities by the Emperor – whereas Goffredo was given them. In 1135 Florence attacked Goffredo's lands and allies and the following year, Goffredo was chased out. He was reinstated soon after but never regained urban support. Further efforts to reimpose his authority failed (abortive attempt to capture the castle of Guidingo di Montedicroce). |
| Although it is clear that the city had increasing scope of autonomy is not possible to identify the leaders. Constant changes of leadership. The Bishop also lost the support of the rural aristocracy who were more interested in establishing their own autonomy from the city. |
| The old aristocracy (i.e. that linked to imperial rule) had little role in the city. |
| An ancestor of the Giandonati was identified as gestald in the 1130s. |
| At the turn of the 12th century, there were leadership roles (but without titles) for members of the Donato and Caponsacchi families but their influence was purely personal. |
| The identities of the governing group remained obscure until the breaking of ties with the old aristocracy. Membership of this group was drawn from a narrow group of important families. |
| It is wrong to describe to the early communes all the powers of what is usually meant by an 'city-state'. It is possible that there was a collection of different nuclei of power, not necessarily totally private. |
| For a long time, the consulate was informal, fluid. The end of the 12th century, there were various centres of power of which the consulate was one. |
| Sanzanome's Assertion that 1125 was the beginning of the consuls cannot be verified – and they may have existed before. There was a time gap of hundred years to the time that he was writing. He mentions no names (a deliberate choice). |
| Only four names are known prior to the 1170s (a period of political tension) and only their first names are known which makes it difficult to situate them in their family. |
| 1150 saw the attempts by Barbarossa to establish his rule in Italy. 1160:1st appearance in Tuscany of Welf IV (Barbarossa's uncle) who had been named Marquis eight years earlier. At first he was regarded as a notable visitor with no intention to interfere politically in the area. But from 1163, Barbarossa established direct rule ignoring marquisorial rights (appointment of Rainhold von Dassel as Arch-chancellor of Italy). Establishment of the league of Tuscan cities with German officials to control the territory and to collect taxes with its capital at San Miniato. |
| Some Florentines were in the imperial entourage or took part in the Diet of San Genesio (1160). Few names are known for the period from the 1130s to the 1160s (lack of documentation or a fact?). More is known from the 1170s onwards but information is still very sparse and episodic. |
| Between 1172 and 1176, members of 19 families had roles (25 are identifiable out of 33 names mentioned). Five of these families had only emerged recently and some old families (Visdomini and Tosinghi) are missing. Not all of these families came from the highest rank; the representation was quite broad and fluid. Other names appear as signatories to important communal acts in consular roles. |
| There are indications that the participation of consuls in important decision-making was necessary but not sufficient – others were needed. The consulate was still fluid and informal and the role of the consuls was modest. In the earliest extant treaty between Florence and another city (Pisa 1171), the consuls only have a limited role – management of war but not anything else. The treaty with Empoli (1182) even hints that it was possible for there to be no consuls in Florence at times. |
| The years following, Florence was increasingly active militarily which gave the consuls a more dominating role. In addition, they had increased control over the contado. |
| At this time there are also existed 'consules mercatorum', often drawn from the same families as the consulate but also from the old establishment who had only risen to the consulate in the last decades of the 12th of the beginning of the 13th century. There were also members from new families (i.e. those who had not yet had consuls from within their ranks). |
| The term 'consules militum' is only found in the beginning of the 13th century, mostly in connection with old families. All three sets of consuls had similar social characteristics: in effect it was a continuation of of ways. Various groups concerned with various things and where the consulate was only one of many such groups. |
| It is unlikely that the consulate had internal jurisdiction in the city before the end of the 12th century. |
| Faini suggests that the origin of the consulate was as a group of men skilled as arbitrators in civil lawsuits but also suggests that the involvement in civil matters was the result of earlier jurisdiction in criminal once. |
| Suggestion that, following the collapse of the placiti, various more or less informal forms of justice emerged ad hoc which then coalesced at the end of the 12th century into organised courts. |
| The transition of society and pre-communal era was long and involved economics, social and institutional activities. |
| Consular justice (tribunals)Resulted from the merger of three different strands: formal justice by the royal authority (placiti), decisions taken by legal experts, and informal mediations involving agreements between parties, with others acting as mediators. |
| Alliance between boni homines and legal experts. |
| The formality of the courts was not total – informal arrangements continued long into the communal era. |
| There is a long section here on the occupation of the contado in the last years of the 12th and the beginning of the 13th centuries – it was systematic and organised. |
| Florentine expansionism as an indicator of political independence with a right to control neighbouring territory emerged in the last quarter of the 12th century. At the same time Italian communes were expanding rapidly. Documents increasingly refer to the Florentine consuls as having authority and jurisdiction: 'obbligato' to the Florentine authorities. The commune was becoming institutionalised Florentine officials acted as representatives of the Emperor (piggybacking on his authority). |
| By the early 13th century, Florence was taxing quite distant parts of the contado. |
| The period between 1150s and 1170s, there were occasional visits from German officials acting for the Emperor. But these were not effective, no more than a sort of power-sharing with the commune. |
| In the 1170s, the Fifanti and Giandonati were the most frequent names mentioned in documents but no family established a hegemony. The Fifanti had most links with other families. |
| Interventions by Barbarossa stopped internal Florentine rivalry but it resumed after the Peace of Venice in 1177. |
| Between 1172 and 1176 there were 35 consuls. |
| In the late 12th century, many Italian cities move towards the establishment of podestà as government had become too complicated for communal authority. |
| 1177 – 1180: internal strife in Florence: the Uberti against the others. |
| The 1170s also saw the expansion of the walls; for military reasons but also to bring more the contado under control. |
| The previous division of the city into quarters (named after the gates) was converted to sestieri in the first decades of the 13th century. |
| The physical expansion of the city the political consequences of the expansion of the city – division of the old quarter of Santa Maria into two each under the control of a different family help to ease tensions. |
| Consuls. 18 have been identified as belonging to 12 different families, mostly experienced hands and the government of the city. However, documents from 1180-1197 never speak of 'consules civitatis; this expression only occurs in chronicles. |
| Institutional power was in the hands of the urban aristocracy with the Uberti and Fifanti slightly outdoing the Giandonati. |
| 1193-1195: documents name 2 podestà but no consuls but this does not necessarily mean one-man rule as there is mention of 'consiliari potestatis' (and sometimes 'consules'. |
| 1193: Gerardo Caponsacchi the podestà – a skilled administrator who had a later career as podestà in other cities. |
| The inner circle of Gerardo's advisers were not the usual big hitters in consular affairs and may even have included a German. However many of them were part of the Caponsacchi network [affinity?]. This is the first occasion when a single group could be considered as hegemonic. |
| The Caponsacchi were clients of Henry VI as was the 1195 podestà Ranieri di Gaetano. It appears that this podestà had been imposed by the Emperor. The names of his advisers are not known except one who was the brother of one of Gerardo's advisers. |
| The first podestà phase represents a brisk acceleration in the centralisation of hierarchical power in the city. It also involved families who, although parties elite, had never been directly involved in politics. In addition, they were not knights; the old governing families were excluded. This regime can be considered as the first indicator of the pro/anti imperial divide. |
| Post-1195, there was some confusion as to who was actually in charge. The death of Henry VI in 1197 and is the period of subordination to the Empire. There was no more podestà and the number of consuls increases (17 in 1197). However there was soon a political crisis and there was recourse to an external podestà in the first decade of the 13th century. Post-1197, a significant number of previously important families were no longer in the administration (e.g.Caponsacchi, Uberti and Buondelmonti) but they reappear in a list of 200 notables as guarantors of a treaty with Siena in 1201. |
| By contrast to the policy of 1185-1195, from 1197 Florence was in an anti-imperial alliance. Gains were made in the contado. |
| From 1193, the governing body was enlarged to include representatives of the guilds (these were not members of the high elite). They were not mentioned after 1203-4 but this does not mean that they disappeared. It is possible that the competing factions from delete use these lesson members weapon against each other. |
| The resort to external podestà in 12 and 1201 is probably due to an internal political crisis – but there was a return to the consulate in 1202-1204. The newcomers to consular office were mostly from elite families or with links to them. |
| External wars until 1208 meant that the city resorted to podestà: a) guarantee support from outside; b) provide an effective military commander; c) diminish or stifle internal squabbling. |
| The last named consul - Ruggiero Giandonati - acted alone as a sort of podestà. He was the first from within the city. At the end of the 12th century, and 'urban nobility', not just a few families but a vast network with different social levels and which included rights over the contado. |
| In 11th century, 65% of noble toponyms came from within 10km of the city. It was same in the 12th century and in the first half of this it was 92%. In the first half of the 13th century, only 33% came from within 10 km – the others went out to 50 km. |
| This exploitation of contado was not just confined to the high elite – a factor would be immigrant families in the last decades of the 12th century. |
| An increasing number of properties in the contado were taxed by the city – again immigration factor. Also, city families whose wealth was from banking or commerce acquired territory in the contado, often far from the city even though they continued to reside there. |
| The whole process was centripetal And tend to exacerbate tensions and conflicts among the societas militum, resulting in a perpetual state of conflict within the city. |
| In the 1120s and 1130s, was mass immigration from the contado of people from middle and lower social levels. This lasted until the end of the 12th century. Due to the increasing population contado. |
| The rise in communal power is linked to the death of Matilda and the extinction of the Cadolinghi family. Also by the long conflict between the Emperor and the Marquisate. |
| Note |
![]()