Notes: Wickham (various)
Sources:
Wickham, C. , Early Medieval Italy: Central Power and Local Society 400-1000 (London: Macmillan, 1981)
Wickham, C. , Sleepwalking into a New World: The Emergence of the Italian City Communes in the Twelfth Century (Princeton: Princeton UP, 2015)
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Page | Note |
|---|---|
| Early Medieval Italy | |
| 14 | Roman period: semi-independent city states run by their own councils – local identity persisted even after the system broke down. Such is the permanent focus for traditional territories. 'When the state falls, Italy itself falls apart'. When the northern Italian state fell (10th/11th centuries), a network of cities survived and replaced it. |
| 19 | City councils lost influence with the Lombard invasion but bishops institutionally supreme. Secular rivals (gastalds, dukes, counts) usually local nobles – represented central authority – bishops represented the city. |
| 21 | 497: Anastasius I accepts that Italy no longer part of the Empire. |
| 28 | Lombard political institutions preserved almost in toto after 774. |
| 32 | Authari (king of Lombards) paid tribute to the Franks. |
| 39 | Officials at the Lombard court functioned partially as missi. |
| 40 | The Lombard army organised locally under command of the Dukes – meant that the state depended on the consent of the landed elites – from Lombard period onward. |
| 41 | The Lombard local administration was based on dukes/gastalds who lived in cities. Dukes were army leaders, gastalds originally local fiscal administrators. Some places only had gastalds who sometimes replaced rebel dukes. |
| 42 | Both Dukes and gastalds enjoyed local loyalty but, with few exceptions, no traces of hereditacy. |
| 42 | The basic local unit for the Lombard state: city/contado. |
| 45 | Lombard kings (like all mediaeval rulers) powerless against abuses of power by local representatives as they relied on them. |
| 45 | Francia was always more powerful than the Lombards and the latter tried to keep on friendly terms. Military cooperation against the Arabs. Gregory III gets no help against Liutprand (740) but the Byzantine Empire was not willing/able to help which meant that popes had to rely on the Franks. |
| 47 | The Lombard kingdom was which are militarily than the Franks but Charlemagne took over a strong and well organised state |
| 48 | Charlemagne waited for Lombard Dukes to die before replacing them. |
| 48 | By 814, most Lombard dukes had become accounts and were Franks/Alemanns. Similarity between Lombard and Carolingian social structures. |
| 48-49 | Despite nominal independence, the Duchy of Rome, the former Exarchate of Ravenna and Spoleto were de facto under Carolingian rule. |
| 49 | Benevento remained Lombard until the Norman conquest in the late 11th century. Naples, Amalfi, Otranto and Calabria also non-Carolingian (part of the Byzantine Empire). |
| 50 | Louis the Pious was never in Italy. Lothar was in Italy a lot but was not interested in it – also he lived on his estates and not in the cities. No Lombard appointments. |
| 50 | 834: break with Louis the Pious – large influx of northern immigrants for Lothar's placement. However, Italy starting to divert from the rest of the Frankish Empire. |
| 50-51 | Little documentation for the period 744-888. |
| 51 | Louis II spent his entire reign initially. |
| 51 | In Lothar's absence, administration Italy based on Lombard patterns as found by Charlemagne. |
| 52 | Kings needed: a) consent of his nobles: b) some control over their actions. In the Empire generally, kings had not much success with b) and only got a) with gifts. Easier in Italy as Lombard kingship had sufficient monarchical power to get support from relatively small gifts – and used ecclesiastical land for gifts rather than the royal demesne. |
| 53 | Carolingian kings very interventionist in ruling Italy. |
| 53 | Carolingian kings relied heavily on their counts – increase in comital responsibility during the ninth century due to their being local military leaders. |
| 54 | Missi were not a Carolingian invention – Lombards had use them – but the Carolingian's made them a basic part of their rule. |
| 55 | Unlike the Lombards, the Carolingian is used ecclesiastical (especially bishops) as instruments of government. Bishops, except the most important, were usually Lombard. |
| 56 | The Lombard conquest at first prevented an extension of episcopal power by the eighth century, bishops were the biggest landowners in city territories – closely connected to local elite families. Lombard aristocrats kept out of the state network – but were supreme locally. Locally selected bishops were Lombards – indicates that Frankish power never went deep in Italy. |
| 56 | Power clashes between counts and bishops as Carolingian kings relied more and more on bishops – bishops given immunity against counts. |
| 58 | Counts had interests in more than one area; they were powerful but dependent upon the king. If the territory was combined to one area they were weaker but potentially more dangerous to the cohesion of the kingdom. Especially the three great marches: Friuli, Spoleto (ex-Lombard) and Tuscany (the latter a development of the early ninth century). The rulers of the marches could be loyal (Friuli) or looking out for themselves (Spoleto). Boniface of Tuscany and his son Adalbert I (846-886) were rulers of much of Tuscany, their power almost vice regal. |
| 59-60 | In the unrest/civil war post-Louis II, Adalbert II (886-915) ruler of a de facto independent state – stayed away from the conflict. |
| 60 | Tuscany's coherence outlived that of the Italian state itself. |
| 60 | Although emperor, Louis II had no influence north of the Alps. He was the last person to try and rule Italy as a whole, the way the Lombards had. The next person to try to do so (Hugh 926-947) was unable to do so. |
| 61 | Louis II tries to exert proper control but with limited success. Unable to control the great lords, despite using them in central government. |
| 62 | Louis II's campaign in the south of failure (himself being captured in August 871). |
| 63 | The Lombards of Benevento went over to the Byzantine Empire. |
| 63 | The absence of a male heir after Louis II's death in 965. Equal claims from his two uncles resulted in a 30 year succession dispute and the state fell with it. |
| 64 | Throughout the early mediaeval period, basic social structures and patterns of its aristocracy unchanged regardless of incomers. Firmly linked to the economy. |
| 65 | The early years of Lombard invasion were disastrous but they were never more than 5-8% of the population. Absence of documentary evidence. |
| 67 | Despite the rigours of the early Lombard days, rapid cultural fusion between the Lombards and the Romans... |
| 68-70 | … Language, dress, names, law, personal relationships, laws of property. [Mostly, the Lombards simulating Roman practices] |
| 70 | The Lombard aristocracy move to the cities and took on patterns of Roman urban aristocracy. By the eighth century, it was impossible to tell apart Romans and Lombards in the cities. |
| 71 | The Lombard settlement did not result in a radical change in social structure. When the Franks arrived, Lombards and Romans more alike to each other than to the invaders. |
| 73 | Until the middle of the 10th century, most counts/missi were Franks in northern Italy although Lombard soon appeared in South Tuscany/Spoleto where the Franks never settled. Franks rarely in cities except in an official capacity. In general, Franks did not have great impact on localities to become part of the set from which bishops were appointed (when not chosen by the king, they were Lombard). The Carolingian's did not make state Frankish – only the top echelon in the government and the army. |
| 74 | The focus for social activity was the city – most Franks did not do urban and became marginalised. |
| 77 | Bishops, important in late Roman Italy, ceased to be so in Lombard Italy and only slowly recovered their position. |
| 80 | In the Kingdom of Italy (the North plus Tuscany) there were about 100 municipia. In 1000, three quarters were functioning cities. Cities dominant over their territories politically, socially, economically. |
| 86 | The political and administrative structure of the Lombard/Carolingian regimes remained urban. Also the Church (except for monasteries). |
| 87 | Dear urbanisation of much of the West under the Germanic kingdoms – but mostly restricted to those least affected by Rome [does this include Germany?] |
| 87 | BUT: space when the Italian state decayed, some aristocratic realisation. The 11th century was the low point for political dominance of the Italian cities… |
| 88 | … but counterbalance by the rise of urban communes. |
| 128 | The communes knew that the state was the fount of law and, when laying claim to de facto statehood in the 12th century, did so largely by legislating. |
| 131 | Royal patronage was the key to political recognition. |
| 140 | Private relationships (affinities), although allowing for the quicker mobilisation of troops, we can the fabric of public obligations by 900, Kings left with few men not reliant on lords; Italy a network of clienteles. Upper classes as intermediaries between the state and the rest of society. |
| 140 | Central government less relevant to local affairs – groundwork for full localisation of power in cities and rural castelli (Castle/fortified villages) of the 10th century. |
| 168-169 | Otto I and Henry II had little control over local level in Italy except by occasional large-scale court proceedings. Louis II was local but also had to work within the norms of those who served him. Louis ruled through a complex series of bodies which tended to cancel each hour out to royal advantage. By the late 10th century, counts were just landowners, the state bureaucracy was decaying, lay/ecclesiastical aristocrats more concerned with their own interests. Ottonians as kings of Italy had no direct power. After the destruction of the Pavia Palace (1024), Italy barely existed as a state. Not anarchy but changes in the locus of power: 'pullulation of little powers'. |
| 169 | 875-905: series of civil wars between rival Italian factions – north-west (France/Burgundy) versus north-east (Germany). |
| 169-170 | Carolingian successors to Louis II largely absent from Italy (except for Charles the Fat – who did nothing). |
| 170 | Berengar of Friuli chosen to succeed Charles the Fat (Carolingian through the female line) in 887. 889 Guy of Spoleto defeats Berengar. 894: intervention of Arnulf/death of Guy. 895-6:2nd intervention by Arnold but a stroke forces him to retreat. [Wickham says Arnulf was after Italy – but this is contradicted by someone else – check notes]. Death of Lambert 898 – Berengar sole ruler. |
| 171 | Invasions by Magyars and Arabs – Marquis of Ivrea installs Louis of Provence but he leaves 902. Returns in 905 and is blinded. Berengar emperor 915 but only interested in Italy. Calling in of outsiders as king was to stabilise and prevent one faction from dominating the other [similar to later role of podestà]. Outsiders only preferred by Italian elites for their advantage as neutrals. External rulers were all of Carolingian descent but seeing as foreigners by the Frankish elite in Italy who increasingly thought themselves Italian. |
| 172 | The only Italian aristocrat to stay out of the power struggle (as a claimant): Adalbert II of Tuscany (886-915). |
| 172 | Civil wars weakened the bureaucracy – end of the class of professional administrators who were replaced by reliable magnates. |
| 172 | Kings had to tread carefully so as to prevent their supporters from defecting – had to make concessions to followers. Kings had to tolerate irregularities by their supporters. Berengar I the chief offender: alienation of fiscal land, fortifications, rights over town walls, judicial powers, tolls, immunities as outright grants. |
| 173 | Berengar allowed the building of castelli as a bulwark against the Magyars – could not raise an army against them. Every Magyar incursion triggered a revolt against Berengar. |
| 173 | The late Carolingian practice of army service through private patronage clienteles crystallised by Berengar. |
| 174 | Castelli continued to be founded in the 11th/12th centuries seldom with royal sanction. |
| 174 | Berengar's concessions meant collective public responsibilities could not be relied upon Berengar could not deal with the Magyars except – also unpopular with sections of the aristocracy. Having privatised defence, Berengar alienated large amounts of the fisc to gain and maintain support. Usually given to bishops as a counterweight to the counts (who controlled the military) – bishops became more powerful in their own right, gaining advantage over the counts. |
| 174-175 | Episcopal power was particularly strong in cities – full comital rights, restricting counts to the countryside. This process continued by Otto I. By the end of the 10th century, bishops dominant in most cities in Emilia, Veneto and partly in Lombardy but Piedmont and Tuscany were largely lay. |
| 175 | Usually side with bishops in disputes with the counts as they were less likely to be politically partisan and their offices were not hereditary. Cities in the hands of bishops and even in the countryside by immunities granted for Church land, especially castelli. Berengar/Hugh of Provence regarded great comital families as enemies and tried to undermine them. Their actions prevented public power falling into the hands of the lay aristocracy. Cities and castelli-based independent foci of public authority. |
| 176 | Bishops not able to maintain private control over cities. Fragmentation of rural authority created a strong rural aristocracy with judicial rights (causing problems later for city communes when trying to control them). |
| 176-177 | Once powers were given to bishops they were lost to the king as they could not be reclaimed (juridical immunity). |
| 177 | Unlike Leighton Holdings, episcopal ones tended to be localised within the diocese, so bishops had no need of the protection of state. Lay holdings followed this pattern, putting more pressure on the state. |
| 179 | Berengar defeated at Fiorenzuola 923 – removed and then assassinated (924 – 925). Rudolf II of Burgundy then Hugh of Provence (926-947). |
| 177-178 | Hugh unable to rule as active king due to the entrenched powers of the aristocracy. Hugh restricted to making or unmaking individuals/families in an attempt to secure his position. Attempts to control the powerful marches – Ivrea, Tuscany, Spoleto – even Rome (marriage to Marozia) Usually by placing his own family in offices. Whose chief concern – invasion from Germany which was being encouraged by his opponents in Italy. |
| 178-179 | Hugh's actions alienated potential supporters. |
| 179 | 945: Berengar of Ivrea invades with a German army – Hugh sidelined and dies 947. The son Lothar dies 950 – Berengar as king. Berengar the final rejection by the Italian aristocracy of a strong king. Hugh's magnates did not hold their land from him – only links were personal loyalty. |
| 179 | Berengar in sole command of a worthless structure. |
| 180 | 951-2: Otto I claims kingdom. Berengar II goes to Germany to be recognised as king under Otto's protection. 961-2: Otto I annexes Italy. All efforts by Berengar to assert authority met by resistance. Comital court disappeared altogether. By 962, the independent Italian kingdom had virtually dissolved. |
| 180 | Otto shored up the state to some extent – raised up the Obertenghi and Canossa - but his influence only possible because of his military strength. After Otto's death (973), German rulers stayed away from Italy until 996. Disintegration restarted. Halted somewhat under Otto III (996-1002) but then resumed. |
| 181 | Henry II strong enough to deal with Arduin of Ivrea without a battle but thereafter no Italian factions called on Germany for assistance to revive the state other than for their own private and local advantage. |
| 181 | Important aristocratic families of 1000 were for the most part creations of Hugh and Otto I. These new families had no previous association with the state and no memory of Carolingian rule. Not interested in the wider concerns of the kingdom. Lands were compact – not scattered throughout the Empire. |
| 182 | Their power not based on office holding – but Tuscany an outrider and where the force of the state remained longest. |
| 183 | House of Canossa the only major family in Emilia to restrict itself to office holding. Founded by Adalbert-Atto, much rewarded by Otto I. His grandson Boniface wielded vast power increased by more royal patronage. |
| 184 | Boniface made Marquis of Tuscany by Conrad II in 1027. Exceptionally, the Canossa Road largely from the countryside. This was only possible in the brief period between city-based Carolingian administration and the city communes. Incastellamento and office holding could work – but real power (episcopal network) under control of the cities. |
| 184 | Tuscany is a bit different. Adalbert ruled autonomously – but even before his death in 915, private encroachments had begun (episcopal). |
| 184-185 | At about Se being a minor allowed Berengar to install counts in Tuscan cities as counterweights to the marquesses. |
| 185 | Tuscan coherence continued until the death of Hugh of Provence's grandson in 1001. The Canossa took over the title but had little land and powers in Tuscany. Tuscan March concentrated in a heavily urbanised area – explained survival. |
| 188 | Cities acting as collectivities (at least informally) since the late seventh century. |
| 189 | When 10th century kings gave comital rights in cities to bishops – retreat from a political sphere that had always been dominated by the episcopacy. But the first responsibility of a bishop was to his church and the city – not state. Cities developed more localised policies – intercity conflict (Pisa-Lucca 1004). |
| 189 | Bishops didn't have things their own way. Urban collectivities not easily controlled – most important urban families also major rural landowners as well. |
| 189 | Only one family could have the Bishop at any one time – no other way to get power and status – hence increase in faction fighting. Only resolved by development of communal government which created new urban offices. |
| 189-190 | The public institutions that remained in cities as the germ of the development of the commune (run by professional administrators (judges/notaries). Well established by the eighth century, by the 11th century had become dominant families. Urban aristocracy needed them and the two groups began to merge to become the leading citizens of the 10th 11th centuries – cives. |
| 190 | In cities, fighting not restricted to the elite. Uprisings as indications of development of cities into autonomous political centres. Became more common after the mid-10th century. |
| 191 | By Conrad II's time, cities the standard bearers of local authority – Conrad's chief opponent. Urban aristocracy detaches itself from rural counterparts and became more powerful than the bishop. |
| 192 | Ultimately, the Lombard/Carolingian regimes were leftovers from the Roman Empire but without the economic resources to back them. |
| Sleepwalking into a New World | |
| 2 | Consuls named in a Milan document of 1117. |
| 5 – 6 | Communes institutionally creative and founded with bottom up collaboration – but also had elite values and rivalries as well. |
| 6 | In 1050 (say), cities were run by the usual aristocrats, military leaders and clerical elites as part of an upward facing hierarchy. By 1150, the same elites were in power but there was no hierarchy above them. |
| 6 | Barbarossa's was 'the most serious attempt to conquer Italy for 200 years'. |
| 7 | Documentation is scarce. |
| 8 | Leadership of the communes was not exclusively mercantile or artisanal. The presence of aristocrats made the city is more powerful. |
| 8 | Economic development was a factor but it was not necessary for the creation of a commune – e.g. Bergamo and Parma. |
| 9 | Communes were not created by 'class' conflict – landed elites were in charge – result of compromise between the parties – bishops, urban leaders, contado leaders. |
| 9 | Confusion caused by Investiture Dispute: civil war leading to the breakdown of authority in the kingdom. Communes were a defensive reaction to a crisis. |
| 10 | Polities were not called 'communes' until the mid 12th century but 'civitates' (cities). Before 1120, 'commune' was an adjective or an advert. Continuity during the transition process was provided by judges. |
| 10 – 11 | The public face of the kingdom was the placita (justice in the presence of a large assembly) – they disappeared in the late 11th century. |
| 11 – 13 | There is a historiographical debate about how 'civic' or how 'landed' communes were. |
| 13 | Maire Vigueur 'Cavaliers et citoyens': the urban armed knights were in charge (mixture of the typical military caste and urban bourgeoisie). |
| 14 | Urban stratification based on wealth [i.e. not class]. |
| 14 – 15 | The beginning of communes is usually dated by the first mention of consuls but these are chance occurrences [scarce documentation – see Faini]– they could have existed earlier [terminus ante quem]. |
| 15 | Communes may also have existed without consuls. |
| 15 | The ideal type for a commune: a conscious urban collectivity; regularly rotating set of magistrates chosen/validated by the community (i.e. not imposed from above); de facto autonomy of action – war, justice, taxation, legislation. |
| 16 | Consuls widely accepted as city rulers by the 1150s. |
| 17 | For Wickham, a crucial marker is the presence of regular consular records. |
| 18 | At the beginning, communes were very informal – replacing older, formal hierarchies of Carolingian and post-Carolingian world which had lost force in the civil wars of the late 11th century. |
| 19 | Commune building an ad hoc process – they were making up as they went along... |
| 20 | … Creating something new while pretending that they were not. |
| 20 | 1097: a Cremona document refers to 'consulatu civium'. |
| 27 | Consulatus' is a term is important as it implies an institution rather than an ad hoc group of people. |
| 33 – 38 | In Milan, pre-1138, 'consulati' were largely inchoate and aristocratic. |
| 38 | Milan: no aristocrats in the 1138 list of consuls but they later returned in smaller numbers. A large number of the non-aristocrats were lawyers. |
| 61 | Milan: Even if the consuls were not aristocrats, they identified with them. |
| 68 | In the early 12th century, Italian cities were all going through similar processes. |
| 69 | Pisa/Genoa the earliest communes (circa 1110); the first references to consuls in Pisa in the 1080s. |
| 73 | The Marquisate of Tuscany was dominant in Pisa at least until the 1070s. |
| 75 | Pisa: 1060 – 1070s, under the rule of Marquis Gottefredo (died 1069) then his widow Beatrice and then his daughter Matilda. |
| 75 | Tuscany was the most stable political structure in the 11th century in the kingdom – dominated by the marquis and placita. |
| 75 | Matilda was 30 when she succeeded her mother in 1076. |
| 76 | Henry V deposes Matilda in 1081. He leaves in 1084. Matilda was not replaced but she left Tuscany for 15 years. |
| 83 | Differing meanings of the term 'consul': can just mean any nonroyal ruler (including counts, dukes, et cetera). |
| 86 | In Pisa, the consulate filled the gap caused by the absence of Matilda (1081-1096) – and also the absence of the bishop. |
| 87 | Formalisation of a city assembly was part of the ad hoc defensive arrangements in a civil war – not the same as a commune. |
| 87 | Matilda were still powerful in Tuscany after her return. |
| 88 | Matilda's successor, Rabodo much weaker. [Matilda's successors as either Marquis or Imperial Vicar were all German aristocrats and appointees of the Emperor. See also Rubinstein 'Beginnings of Political Thought in Florence'.]. |
| 88 | In Pisa, there was a sort of power-sharing between the Archbishop, the master of the cathedral works and the consuls (1103)… |
| 89 | … But consuls everywhere post 1109 – gradually taking control from the Archbishop. |
| 90 | In Milan, consuls were part of the Archbishop's entourage but later they were lawyers rather than aristocrats. In Pisa, the consuls were never part of the Archbishop's entourage. |
| 92 | In Tuscany, episcopal power was never that great; up to 1080 power was mostly held by the Marquis. |
| 93 | Pisa's commune was firmly in charge by the 1110s. |
| 94 | The pace of establishing a commune in Genoa was the same as in Pisa. |
| 94 – 95 | Difficult to say WHY communes developed. |
| 95 | Wickham's suggestion for elements in the process: military planning; economic importance of nonagricultural land… |
| 96 | … and a lot of common land. |
| 96 | The city assembly a defensive reaction to the crisis in traditional government. |
| 97 | In her last years, Matilda was conspicuous by her absence; a stable elite as consuls were elected from a small number of families. |
| 110 – 111 | Prominence in Pisa was down to wealth not position or occupation... |
| 111 | … A plausible hypothesis is that this is the result of the importance to Pisa of trade and foreign military adventures. |
| 111 | No popolo in Pisa until the 1220s. |
| 114 | Suggestion that consuls in Pisa thought of themselves as a stopgap until the traditional system could return (there is some evidence of this in Genoa). |
| 115 | Crystallisation of the commune from ad hoc arrangements from within which were not legitimised by an outside hierarchy. In Pisa the aristocratic world with weaker than in Milan. |
| 119, 120, 122 | Examples of emperors replacing popes (Henry III, V). |
| 122 | Popes with connections to the Marquisate of Tuscany were elective from 1059 onwards, independently of the Emperor… |
| 123 | … Especially Hildebrand/Gregory VII. |
| 161 | Footnote: Florence among 'best of the rest' in terms of documentation. |
| 161 | There is a general assumption that cities borrowed best practices from each other. |
| 164 | Consuls in Genoa are acting formally 1104 – 1105; the first known consular judgement anywhere… |
| 165 | … i.e. in line with Pisa. Consuls from the same social strata as in Pisa. |
| 166 | Pisa/Genoa the earliest organised communes. |
| 171 | Lombardy and Emilia were the heart of the kingdom. Breakup of the power of the kingdom 1080 – 1100. |
| 175 | Consul' – a city leader, first informal then with the growing claim to rulership. |
| 176 – 177 | Concerning Lombardy/Emilia: similar pacing – consuls/assemblies visible by the 1100s; institutionalisation by the 1130s in some cases; and in all by the 1150s. |
| 177 | The failure of the kingdom in its heartland was where early required defensive measures were most present. |
| 177 | Veneto/Romagna: communes found under bishops (not Venice) – generally later than elsewhere. |
| 178 | Romagna/Veneto: Bologna the most active commune (from 1123). |
| 179 | Bologna crystallised as a commune by the 1120s. |
| 179 | Romagna/Veneto: bishops remained important for some time. |
| 180 | Civil wars in Tuscany meant the fast collapse of traditional powers, even in the unusually coherent Marquisate of Tuscany where episcopal power was never that great. But, with the exception of Lucca and Pisa, communes did not develop quickly. By the 1120s, Lucca's consuls are city representatives. |
| 182 | According to Faini, Consuls were first documented in 1138 but very few mentions of them thereafter until the 1170s. The bishop not really present as a political focus. After the death of Matilda (who had used Florence as her powerbase) and the dying out of important families such as the Guidi and Casolinghi created a power vacuum. Also the extinction of most of the rest of the castle-owning aristocrats of the 11th century (who had in anyway left the city for the contado). |
| 183 | Faini: communal elements before 1170 were 'evanescent'. |
| 183 | Florence had a coherent community which included all levels of society but was not very important economically at this time. |
| 183 – 184 | The slowness of development of the Florentine commune is perhaps illusory due to the paucity of documents (Faini). |
| 185 | In Tuscany there was a variety of solutions to the collapse of the Marquisate. |
| 187 passim | Development of towns as communes: 1) economic developed ports (Pisa/Genoa) 2) major inland cities in the heartland of the kingdom (and also Lucca) 3) cities of the Veneto/Romagna/some in Piedmont/Lombardy inland Tuscany/rest of Piedmont. |
| 188 | Florence a 'latent' commune – i.e. one where power goes back and forth between consuls and (say) bishops. |
| 189 | The pacing of the creation of the various elements of the commune ideal type (see page 15) varied from city to city; only military leadership was there from the start. |
| 191 | Three levels of elites: 1) rich aristocrats/seigneurial; 2) prosperous but not castle owning (fiefs only land or tithes); 3 'medium elite) without much land. Overwhelmingly, consuls elected from the second category. |
| 195 | Assemblies (not consuls) were the main form of defensive reaction to the crisis in the kingdom and the March of Tuscany from the 1080's. Consuls came later; first ad hoc but later institutionalised. |
| 196 | Assemblies formalise themselves from pre-existing practices of collective action. |
| 197 | Formalisation process: assemblies (even when the leaders were informal); definition of leaders; clearly defined periods of office; a formalised legal system. |
| 198 | The later developments were not defensive in the way that assemblies were. |
| 198 – 199 | Wickham's take on what happened: |
| 198 – 199 | 1) pre-1080s, cities fully integrated into kingdom despite occasional revolts over political or religious matters. |
| 198 – 199 | 2) civil wars caused Pisa/Genoa to act quickly to prevent internal divisions – both already well organised militarily. |
| 198 – 199 | 3) inland: almost constant civil war between Henry IV and Matilda in the 1090s; bishops still available as stop gaps. |
| 199 | Elites made do with the help of bishops to keep things going in the absence of the usual institutions. |
| 200 | Had Barbarossa invaded in the 1110s, he would probably have succeeded. [For what reason – check who was running Germany at that time and also the impact of the death of Matilda]. |
| 200 | The reimposition of central control did not happen for internal German reasons and because the institutional bases (such as placita) had been to weaken. |
| 201 | By 1130s/1140s, consuls seen as the norm, formalising what had become standard practice. Inter-city walls were also a factor driving the formalisation, for example the need to impose taxation to finance wars. |
| 202 | Gradual realisation that there was no going back to the old system; 1130/1140 is the key time in this, meaning that Barbarossa came too late to succeed. |
| 203 | In Florence, the consular regime could be abandoned for substantial periods [no details given]. |
| 204 | Development of the communal myth in the 13th century. |
| Page | Note |
![]()