Notes: La Rocca Italy in the Early Middle Ages
Source: La Rocca, C. (ed.), Italy in the early Middle Ages : 476-1000 (Oxford: Oxford UP, 2002)
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Chapter | Page | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pohl W. : Invasions and ethnic identity | |
| 1 | 22 | After the Lombard invasion: king's power is limited – going importance of bishops as civic leaders. By contrast with the centralised Roman administration as used by Theodoric, the Lombards could only rule by using local civic structures of administration. |
| 1 | 25 | Throughout the Lombard period, the Byzantine Empire maintain communication between Ravenna and Rome via a chain of fortresses along the road through Narni and Perugia (the border between Lombard duchies of Tuscia and Spoleto. |
| 1 | 26 | In the Exarchate, civil lay aristocracy in decline: the church of Rome (especially the Pope) took a larger role in administration. |
| 1 | 26 | As the Byzantines gradually lost control of Italy in the eighth century, some tits began to emerge as more or less independent powers (largest was Rome – but it had Frankish support)... |
| 1 | 27 | … while long-distance trade helped Naples, Amalfi and Gaeta and Venice and Commachio in the north-east. |
| 1 | 27 | The Franks had started to take an interest in Italy as soon as Clovis had created the united kingdom of the Franks around 500. Repeated Frankish interventions in Italy between the Gothic War and the arrival of the Lombards but faded away along with the decline of the Merovingians until Pépin le Bref. Repeated interventions again in the 750s. |
| 1 | 27 | After Charlemagne's intervention, the Pope retains some autonomy in the 'Republic of St Peter' and Benevento accepted Frankish overlordship but was virtually independent unless there was a Frankish army nearby. |
| 1 | 28 | The Lombards had some say in government in the early Carolingian period but gradually elites from the North replace them. Many of these had interests elsewhere in the Empire. However local law prevailed. |
| 1 | 28-29 | The ambiguous nature of Italy: a peripheral colony but also a source of prestigious traditions and skills – the papacy as the source of Christian legitimacy. |
| 1 | 30 | As the Carolingian rule died away, aristocratic families with transalpine origins made bids for power: Berengar of Friuli and Guy of Spoleto. |
| 1 | 30-31 | During the ninth century, Benevento split into a number of regional and local powers. |
| 1 | 31 | Naples and Amalfi took advantage of the situation – the Byzantine Empire re-established as a major power in the region. Muslim conquest of Byzantine Sicily in the 840s. |
| 1 | 32 | During the period of troubles, identity was often attached to cities, including local rivalries: Capua/Naples, Salerno/Amalfi, Siena/Arezzo. |
| 1 | 32 | Teutonici' became the name for those north of the Alps – the Byzantine and Saxon emperors were regarded as outsiders. |
| 1 | 33 | In the second half the 10th century, transalpine interventions (starting with Otto I) brought Italy under foreign control – but indirectly most of the time [due to the physical absence of the king]. In the balance of power between the invaders and local lords, cities began to expand their political influence. |
| 2 | Bougard, F. : Public power and authority | |
| 2 | 34 | With the exception of periods of invasion and weak authority, kings/emperors' authority in Italy was generally recognised as was that of their representatives (more so here than in other parts of the Empire). The Royal Palace was the institutional focus of authority. |
| 2 | 35 | Authority derived primarily from the army – but hereditary/dynastic successions were possible. This had been the norm in the Roman Empire and to some extent with the Lombards. |
| 2 | 38 | The practice of assuming the title of 'king' before actually exercising power and and the tendency to use 'emperor' as an alternative prevented the creation of a tradition of kingship (as opposed to the norm in other parts of the Frankish Empire). Kings increasingly used the authority of papal approbation rather than popular acclamation. |
| 2 | 39 | After the Carolingian conquest, the Lombard kingdom was peripheral to the Empire as a whole but kings did draw on Lombard traditions to enhance their authority. |
| 2 | 40 | The marriage of Adelaide and Otto I link to the German and Italian kingdoms for centuries. |
| 2 | 47-48 | Italy was heavily urbanised – towns as loci of power. |
| 2 | 48 | In northern Italy, the Carolingian/Ottonian kings were often absent from the peninsula and only made short visits: coronations, campaigns or just a general itinerancy. |
| 2 | 50 | Justice was a new function of kingship and kings were judged on how well they performed this task. |
| 2 | 50-51 | The Carolingians institutionalised justice: judicial meetings – assemblies, placiti were held by kings, counts and missi. |
| 2 | 51 | Each area had its own judicial traditions. Importance of judgements being held in public to ensure that the defeated party recognised the decision, therefore the site of the judgement was important. |
| 2 | 52 | From Charlemagne to the Ottonians, hearings drew large crowds. The role of the king's delegates grew between the eighth and 11th centuries overshadowing local judges (scabini)… |
| 2 | 53 | … scabini were in the service of the local count, replacing judges depending on the king. |
| 2 | 54 | Patronage, gifts, benefices, land, share of power as means of maintaining networks of followers. |
| 2 | 56 | In the Carolingian period, Italy became a subordinate part of a larger polity: charters were only issued by rex francorum or the emperor. The absence of the emperors was counterbalanced by their issuing of charters. |
| 2 | 57 | Charters were the means by which Frankish legal practices were introduced into Italy. |
| 2 | 57 | The granting of immunities as a driver in the privatisation of authority – especially in the period of the 'national kings' (888-962)… |
| 2 | 58 | … more than a quarter of the charters issued by Berengar I and Hugh of Provence were to individuals (patronage deals). |
| 2 | 58 | From the 960s, institutionalisation of the delegation of juridical rights creating 'districti'. Of most benefit to bishops who are now replacing the counts as administrators of justice in towns and their surrounding districts (bishops acting as royal missi enhanced their links with the king). |
| 3 | Gasparri, S. : The aristocracy | |
| 3 | 66 | Despite earning considerable landed property the Lombard aristocracy was primarily urban… |
| 3 | 67 | … especially in politically important cities like Cividale, capital of the powerful Duchy of Friuli. |
| 3 | 69 | The Lombard elites contained those whose fortune consisted of money – not land – were expected to be mobilised like landowners. References to merchants. |
| 3 | 69 | Lombard kings made large gifts to their followers, especially gasindi (formalised relationship of patronage). The aristocracy drew much of its power due to geographical proximity to the royal power. |
| 3 | 73 | The Lombard rebellion in Friuli in 776 resulted in Charlemagne replacing the Lombard aristocrats with Franks. |
| 3 | 74 | Difficult for Franks to established industries in Italy until Lothar was sent to Italy post 834. Lothar's supporters were cut off from their properties and benefices north of the Alps and had to put down roots in Italy – Unrochings and Widonians (Friuli and Spoleto). The counts and marquesses of Tuscany were descendants of a certain Boniface [presumably a Frank] who lived in the 820s. |
| 3 | 77 | All of the families of the high aristocracy in Carolingian times had week routes in the cities despite family members being counts or bishops – more important was the relationship to the Carolingian dynasty – giving rise to dynastic ambitions. The lesser aristocracy were more closely linked to the city. |
| 3 | 77 | Outside of the Lombard/Carolingian kingdom, aristocracy closely linked to the cities (primary source of their political strength – e.g. mid-ninth century nobles in Rome who controlled the papacy). |
| 3 | 78 | Benevento and its successor polities: rulers owned urban property even though their wealth came from land. Ditto Naples – all had close links between urban power and episcopal authority. |
| 3 | 79 | The Berengar/Guy rivalry began a period of political instability until the advent of Otto I. Between the end of the ninth and the mid-10th centuries, all the principal families of the Carolingian period disappeared and were replaced by others. |
| 3 | 79-80 | Origins of the replacement families is uncertain – someone from Frankish and some from Lombard origins |
| 3 | 80 | Adalbert Atto was from Lucca and Rose when he joined Otto I. Referred to as a marquis before actually obtaining the territory. |
| 3 | 80 | 'Marquis' could be a rank (more important than a count) without actually being associated with the territory… |
| 3 | 81 | … and their own property could cut across administrative boundaries. |
| 3 | 81 | Collapse of the unified political/administrative structures [due to rivalries at the top?] – rise of forms of seigneurial power (both the cause and consequence) – incastellamento: constructed independently by ruling families – and only retrospectively authorised. Castles and their surrounding areas (districtus) became centres of seigneurial power as the aristocrats abandon the cities – rise in power of bishops, reinforced by royal grants to fortify cities and urban government. |
| 3 | 82 | The political character of the post Carolingian world permitted the rise of powerful aristocratic families. |
| 3 | 82-83 | During the 10th century, the increasingly effective episcopal power in the cities accentuated the rural character of aristocratic power. The lack of involvement of the aristocracy in the cities prevented any formation of a regional/subregional territorial political system – leaving the city and its contado as the basic political unit. |
| 3 | 83 | Cities as the central axes of political life. |
| 3 | 83 | The absence of the higher aristocrats from the cities allow bishops to become dominant, who then recruited followers (capitanei) many of whom had landed properties and lordship rights in the country. |
| 3 | 84 | Despite their castles, at the close of the first millennium, even important aristocratic families were drawn to the cities. |
| 4 | ||
| 4 | Azzara, C. : Ecclesiastical institutions | |
| 4 | 87 | Gradual decline of the governmental structures of the late Roman Empire meant that Western bishops often took responsibility for government in their cities. Bishops were normally recruited from aristocratic families and so had the necessary expertise: provision of food, city defence, etc. Bishops were the last representatives of the old ruling class and were still trusted by the populace. The Roman state had granted bishops certain rights to civil administration, a practice continued by the Visigoths and the Ostrogoths. |
| 4 | 88 | Collapse of episcopal networks with the Lombard invasion – also impacted by the prior Gothic war. |
| 4 | 89 | The period between the conversion of the Lombard elites to Catholicism and the establishment of the Carolingian regime was important for the development of ecclesiastical institutions: lay and ecclesiastical institutions were interdependent. |
| 4 | 90 | The proliferation of rural church building in the 7th/8th centuries much influenced by lay elites wanting religious properties on their land for prestige reasons (also private devotions). |
| 4 | 93 | Powerful layman who founded religious buildings wanted to reserve for themselves the selection of the clergy. |
| 4 | 97 | The establishment of Carolingian power generated new ties between the great monasteries, political power and aristocratic interests. Franks began to hold high office in abbeys; massive increase in ecclesiastical property together with the granting of fiscal and juridical immunities – monasteries as political supporters of the Carolingian regime. |
| 4 | 97-98 | Decline of central power the ninth century allowed ecclesiastical bodies with immunities to become independent (as have lay ones) – even developing systems of vassalage. |
| 4 | 98 | Newly established seigneurial dynasties used new monasteries to strengthen their positions. Monasteries would ward off attempts to encroach on their patch (by both lay men and bishops). |
| 4 | 98 | Saxon emperors also looked to monasteries to maintain their authority in Italy. |
| 4 | 99 | With the collapse of the public administrative districts in the 10th century, bishops/abbots with immunities took over political authority of populations on ecclesiastical land. With the Saxon emperors, bishops again given privileges within cities and land owned by the church or bishop – took on administration and came to to fully represent the cives… |
| 4 | 99 | … But less able to control ecclesiastical affairs due to the proliferation of private churches. |
| 4 | 99-100 | Interdependence of ecclesiastical and lay institutions led to tensions/strain: resistance to lay powers over the Church plus resistance to the involvement of ecclesiastics in worldly affairs. |
| 5 | Azzara, C. : The papacy | |
| 5 | 104-105 | Gelasius I the originator of the doctrine of authority split between church and emperor (482)… … implied the primacy of the sacred over the political. |
| 5 | 105 | The collapse of political authority in fifth century Italy forced the Pope to take on a political role as well as a spiritual one. |
| 5 | 105-106 | As long as the barbarian rulers were Arian or pagan, populations in the former Western Empire look to Rome but this ceased with the rulers converted to Catholicism. |
| 5 | 106 | Disintegration of episcopal networks following the Lombard invasion. |
| 5 | 106 | Gregory the Great negotiated a deal with the Lombards due to the inertia of the Imperial authorities, including taking decisions that were not liked by them. |
| 5 | 106-107 | Absent the imperial institutions, popes had to take on civil administration of Rome, especially defence – and later that of all central and southern Italy. |
| 5 | 108 | To do this, the Popes created an effective bureaucracy. |
| 5 | 109-110 | The Lombards came round to Catholicism in the seventh century but it was only a modus vivendi – the popes' allegiance to the Empire remained, despite occasional problems – e.g. the iconoclast dispute. |
| 5 | 110 | Byzantine weakness encourage Lombard aggression – capture of the Exarchate (751) – papal request to the Franks etc. |
| 5 | 111 | In effect, the papacy was laying claims to replace the Empire in northern and central Italy with Frankish assistance. |
| 5 | 111 | The actions of Desiderius against Rome persuades Charlemagne to intervene (774). |
| 5 | 111-112 | The popes' sovereign rights only extended over an area equivalent to present-day Lazio. |
| 5 | 112 | Papacy's abandonment of Byzantium for the Franks caused by political expediency – not part of a long-term strategy. |
| 5 | 113 | Charlemagne encourage the creation of an empire wide hierarchical structure for the church: Pope – Archbishop – Bishop – and also Benedictine rule in monasteries… |
| 5 | 114 | … As a means to enhancing overall political control – the popes themselves were only marginally involved in this effort. |
| 5 | 115 | The disintegration of the Carolingian Empire did not result in any concomitant increase in papal authority as there was no way to impose administrative structures further. From the end of the 9th to the mid-11th centuries, the papacy was the prey of Roman aristocratic families. |
| 5 | 115 | Intervention of Henry III in 1046: imposes series of German popes nominated by the emperor |
| 5 | 116 | Papacy becomes the focal point for church reform – and the end to lay influence. The 1059 Lateran Council reserves the election of Pope's to the College of Cardinals. 1075: Dictatus papae (Gregory VII) – total dependence of the episcopate on the pope. Supremacy over the church needs to claims to authority over the whole of society. |
| 7 | Francovich, R. : Changing structures of settlements | |
| 7 | 152 | Because it was caused by the militarisation of society in the countryside. Shifting internal borders meant the need for fortified settlements in strategic locations to control the territory. Gothic/Byzantine/Lombard castles were public works not private initiatives as later on. |
| 7 | 152-153 | Many castles abandon once they were no longer required but some became centres for economic or administrative activities. |
| 7 | 159 | Mid-seventh century: return to hilltop and mountain settlements – a centralising process that would later lead to settlements becoming castles. |
| 7 | 160 | Rise of a hierarchy in hilltop villages between ninth and 10th centuries – development of lordships – social division with aristocratic groups reorganising landed property power relations. |
| 7 | 160 | Formation of hilltop villages contemporaneous with foundation of monasteries. |
| 7 | 161 | As early as the ninth century, some monasteries were in decline and their parish churches were brought under the aegis of the castles. |
| 7 | 164 | Tuscany: during the seventh century, all poorer forms of settlement abandoned in favour of hilltop villages which were occupied until the 13th century. |
| 8 | Gelichi, S. : The cities | |
| 8 | 170 | Many cities of classical antiquity survived into the early Middle Ages: sizeable populations; seats of public/ecclesiastical authority; places of aristocratic residence; and centres of trade. But also new foundations. |
| 8 | 170-171 | In the Carolingian period, Italy was still dotted with cities (probably more than elsewhere in Islamic or Byzantine Mediterranean. |
| 8 | 171 | In northern Italy, most cities of Antiquity survive – but some were redundant and did not. |
| 8 | 173 | By the sixth century, 50% of urban settlements in the south had been abandoned. |
| 9 | Villa, C. : Lay and ecclesiastical culture | |
| 9 | 197 | Even before the fall of Pavia in 774, relations were close between the Franks and the Lombards – Pippin of Herstal space (father of Charles Martel) sent as a pupil to Liutprand… |
| 9 | 198 | … as part of a reciprocal cultural exchange. |
| Chapter | Page | Note |
![]()