Historical Summary
This page gives a broad summary of the major events of the period. It does not attempt to give any analysis of political, economic or social trends during this period; these can be found elsewhere.
Based upon who was at least nominally ruling northern Italy, broadly speaking the time can be divided into eight periods:1The names below are convenient handles, not necessarily strict definitions. For example, the first part of the Ostrogoth period includes the seventeen years between the deposition by Odoacer of the last Western emperor (476) and Odoacer’s own overthrow by Theodoric, King of the Ostrogoths in 493). Also, Hohenstaufen rule in Italy continued beyond the period covered here.
- Ostrogoth (476-568)
- Lombard (568-774)
- Carolingian (774-887)
- Post-Carolingian (887-961)
- Ottonian (961-1024)
- Salian (1024-1137)
- Hohenstaufen (1137-1200)
The last years of the Western Empire were characterised by weak emperors with effective rule being exercised by Germanic military leaders. It was one of these, Odoacer, who removed Romulus Augustulus (the last Western emperor) in 476 and who then ruled himself in the name of Zeno, the Eastern (Byzantine) emperor. In 489, the Ostrogoths under their king Theodoric migrated to Italy, encouraged to do so by Zeno who saw both Odoacer and Theodoric as potential rivals. A four year war ensued which ended in the death of Odoacer and victory for Theodoric. A strong and capable ruler, Theodoric recovered large areas of the former Roman Empire but his rule was being challenged by the time of his death in 526. He was succeeded by his ten year old grandson, Athalaric. After Theodoric’s death, weaknesses in the Ostrogothic regime encouraged Emperor Justinian I to try and bring Italy back into direct Byzantine rule. Justinian was successful but the twenty year war it entailed was disastrous for the peninsula and eased the way for the Lombard invasion.
In 568, the Lombards, a Germanic tribe previously living in what is now Austria, invaded northern Italy and established a kingdom with its capital at Pavia. Two autonomous duchies were also set up at Spoleto and Benevento south of a strip of territory running from Ravenna to Rome which remained in Byzantine hands. Unlike the Ostrogoths, whose king Theodoric had been exposed to them while a hostage in Constantinople, the Lombards were alien to Roman institutions and destroyed the existing social and governmental infrastructure. Because of the relationship between the king and local leaders, the Lombard kingdom was unstable and between 574 and 584, there was no king at all. However, contact with non-Lombard areas, particularly those controlled by the popes, gradually led to a process of civilisation of Lombard society. Nevertheless, tensions remained, especially in times of Lombard expansionism. The capture of Ravenna in 751 induced the popes to request assistance from the Franks. Ravenna was returned to the papacy but when the Lombard kingdom was overrun by Charlemagne in 774, he incorporated it into his own empire. The outlying duchies of Spoleto and Benevento remained independent.
Charlemagne’s takeover of the Lombard kingdom fundamentally changed the political landscape in Italy in two ways. First, coupled with his subsequent annexation of Istria, it destroyed any remaining aspirations in the Byzantine Empire for the recovery of its former territories in northern Italy. Secondly, by installing Frankish counts to act as his local representatives, Charlemagne sowed the seeds of the resistance to central authority which contributed to the reduction in the ability of later emperors to influence affairs in the peninsula.
With the exception of the reigns of Lothar II and Louis II, for much of the hundred years of Carolingian rule Italy was of secondary interest to its rulers. In addition to the external threats to which they were exposed from most directions (Vikings, Slavs, Saracens), Carolingian rulers were increasingly preoccupied with internal disputes over territory, compounded by the Frankish preference for partible inheritance rather than primogeniture. In 806, Charlemagne had published a decree stipulating that, on his death, the Empire was to be divided between his sons. In fact, when he did die in 814, only one son had survived, Louis the Pious, who was thus able to inherit the entire Empire. Louis’s own attempts to pass everything onto his eldest son Lothar failed in the face of opposition from his younger sons and he was compelled to agree to a division of the Empire after his death. When this occurred in 840, Lothar made a renewed attempt to impose himself but was defeated and, by the Treaty of Verdun in 843, the Empire was formally divided into three separate regimes: Charles the Bald received West Francia, Louis the German East Francia and Lothar the central section (Lotharingia) which included Italy as well as the title of Emperor.
Further fragmentation occurred in 855 when, with the death of Lothar, his territory was divided between his three sons: Louis II (Italy), Lothar II (the northern part of the territory north of the Alps), and Charles (Burgundy and Provence). Charles died in 863 and his territory was divided between his two brothers. The deaths of Lothar II (869) and the childless Louis II (875) resulted in the elimination of Lotharingia. Lothar II’s territories were divided between his uncles Charles the Bald and Louis the German with the former succeeding Louis II as King of Italy.
When Charles the Bald himself died in 877, he was succeeded in Italy by Carloman, eldest son of Louis the German. In 879, Carloman was obliged to abdicate following a stroke and was succeeded by his younger brother Charles the Fat. In 884, Charles the Fat also inherited West Francia from his childless cousin Carloman II thus reuniting the whole of the Frankish Empire. However, Charles’s incompetence led to his deposition in 887 and Carolingian rule in northern Italy came to an end.
The removal from power of Charles the Fat resulted in a long period of political unrest throughout most of the former Carolingian Empire. In West Francia, confronted by powerful regional magnates, royal authority collapsed and the kingdom would never again provide a candidate for the imperial throne. In East Francia, there was a series of succession crises, only resolved by the election to the throne of the first non-Frankish king, the Saxon Henry the Fowler, followed by his son, Otto I the Great. Their efforts at centralising power in their own hands and the establishment of a system of primogeniture were ultimately successful but both had to contend with aristocrats opposed to them. In addition, much of their attention was with the open border to the east, either in conquest of new territories or in repelling Magyar raids. Magyar raids also affected West Francia and both kingdoms also had to deal with the Vikings. With the exception of the limited and abortive efforts in the 890s of Arnulf of Carinthia (successor to Charles the Fat in East Francia), rulers north of the Alps were unable to intervene in Italian affairs until 951. This situation opened the door for local aristocrats to attempt to gain the kingship of Italy for themselves.
The weakness of the late Carolingian kings had forced them to make concessions to the counts, the officials they appointed to act as their local representatives. Concessions included grants of land and the making of the counts’ offices hereditary, thus further weakening the royal authority. In Italy, small landowners sold out to larger ones and by the end of the 9th century, power was in the hands of a few powerful families with counties being amalgamated into marquisates. These aristocrats vied with each other for dominance but, even when a victor emerged, he was rarely able to govern undisturbed for long as those dissatisfied with his rule sought to replace him, frequently calling for armed assistance from outside. With the exception of Rudolf II of Burgundy, all of the contenders had connections with the Carolingian dynasty, either through the female line or by marriage.
An initial conflict between Berengar of Friuli and Guy III of Spoleto and Guy’s son Lambert ended in in favour of Berengar in 898 with the death of Lambert (Guy had died in 894). Adalbert of Tuscany then convinced Louis of Provence to intervene but he was captured and blinded by Berengar and returned to Provence in 905. Opposition to Berengar now centred around his son-in-law, Adalbert of Ivrea. Sometime between 917 and 920, Adalbert convinced Hugh of Provence to invade but he was defeated by Berengar and forced to withdraw. Adalbert now turned to Rudolf II of Burgundy whose invasion in 923 led to the defeat of Berengar and the latter’s assassination a year later.
However, faced with the loss of the benefits of Berengar’s patronage, his supporters turned again to Hugh of Provence whose intervention, this time, was successful and Rudolf II was obliged to withdraw. The two later came to an agreement, with Rudolf taking over Provence in return for dropping his claims to Italy (933). Four years later, Rudolf died. Hugh married his widow and married his son Lothar to Rudolf’s daughter, Adelheid.
Patronage issues were behind the unsuccessful revolt of 940 by Berengar of Ivrea (son of Adalbert and grandson of Berengar of Friuli). Obliged to flee to the court of Otto I in Germany, Berengar returned in 945. He forced Hugh to return to Provence, leaving Hugh’s son Lothar as king with Berengar as his councillor. Lothar died in 950 and Berengar assumed the throne as Berengar II. He attempted to force Lothar’s widow Adelheid to marry his son Adalbert.
Opposition in Italy to Berengar allowed Henry of Bavaria and his son Liudolf to intervene, disturbing the balance of power in the area and causing a reaction from Otto I (Henry’s elder brother). Adelheid also appealed to Otto for help and he came to Pavia with an army and married her (951). Berengar II was deposed and Otto crowned King of Italy. A year later, Berengar was restored to the throne as Otto’s vassal. In 960, Berengar II attacked the Papal domains and John XII called for assistance from Otto. In return for his help, Otto was crowned emperor in 962. Berengar was finally removed in 963 and died three years later.
Louis the Child, the last Carolingian ruler in the male line of East Francia (Germany), died heirless in 911. His successor, Conrad of Franconia, was unable to deal with the constant revolts against his rule by major nobles nor to defend the territory against the regular incursions of the Magyars. He died of wounds incurred in a battle against the rebels in 918. On his deathbed, he recommended as his successor one of his principal opponents, Henry the Fowler, Duke of Saxony. Henry was elected King in 919. His reign (919-936) was dominated by his largely successful efforts to restore royal authority in Germany and in both extending and securing its eastern frontier. He was also able to obtain nominal suzerainty over the other successor states to the Carolingian Empire. Henry had aspirations to be crowned Emperor but died before he could achieve them. His policies were continued by his son, Otto I.
Otto’s successes surpassed his father’s but his reliance on coercion rather than Henry’s preference for negotiated settlements meant that he too had to deal with revolts against his rule. The necessity for both kings to concentrate their efforts north of the Alps meant that Italy was left largely to its own devices resulting in the conflicts described in the previous section. The exception was Otto’s intervention against Berengar II in 951 but, even there, events in the north meant that he was forced to return to Germany, with Berengar reinstated to the throne, nominally as Otto’s vassal.
The situation changed radically in the mid-950s. A major incursion by the Magyars united the German nobles behind Otto and his victory at Lechfeld in 955 permanently ended Magyar raids. With Germany secured, Otto was free to turn his attention to Italy. Unable to resist Berengar II’s threats to papal territory, Pope John XII turned to Otto for assistance in much the same way as Adrian I had turned to Charlemagne against the Lombards in 774. Berengar was removed and Otto declared himself King of the Lombards. A grateful John XII crowned Otto Emperor in 962. The growth in Otto’s power is epitomised by this act. In 951, Otto had negotiated for an imperial crown but had been frustrated in this by Alberic, John XII’s father and the de facto ruler of Rome and its territories.
Despite Otto’s considerable political and military power, it would take a further four years to end resistance to his rule in northern Italy and for him to settle in his favour the perennial conflicts in Rome between the popes and the local aristocracy. For most of the rest of his reign Otto would attempt to increase his influence in southern Italy. Returning to Italy in 966 to rescue Pope John XIII (his own nominee) from the Roman aristocracy, Otto remained there for six years, attempting to seize territory in Byzantine-held Apulia and Calabria. Although these ultimately failed, Otto retained feudal overlordship over Benevento and Capua, and his western emperorship was recognised by the Byzantine Emperor John Tzimiskes. The treaty was sealed in 972 by the marriage of Tzimiskes’ niece Theophanu to Otto I’s son, Otto II (by now co-emperor with his father). Otto I died a year later and was succeeded by his son.
Disputes against Otto II’s rule in Germany kept him away from Italy until 980. Nevertheless, the political structure that his father had imposed there meant that, apart from the usual problems in Rome, there was no opposition to his rule. Encouraged by his Byzantine wife who had fallen out with her relatives in Constantinople, Otto embraced the concept of a Roman emperor who would rule the whole of Italy. He attacked both the Byzantine and Arab territories in the south. His plans were disrupted by the death in 981 of Pandulf Ironhead, the Ottonians’ client in the Lombard principalities. This allowed the Byzantines to recover some of the territory that they had lost to Pandulf. Otto’s actions prompted an alliance between the Byzantines and the Arabs and Otto’s army was comprehensively defeated at Crotone in 982. Forced to return northwards, Otto was stricken with malaria and died in Rome in December 983.
Some months before his death, Otto II had taken the precaution of having his only son, Otto, crowned King of Italy and of Germany as Otto III. Only three years old at the time of his father’s death, the earlier years of his reign were disturbed by rival claims to the regency and by a major uprising by the Slavs in the eastern part of the Empire. The regency dispute was ultimately settled in favour of his mother, Theophanu and, after her death in 991, his paternal grandmother, Adelheid. A significant event of this period was the 987 election of Hugues Capet as King of West Francia. This ended any efforts by the German kings to regain control of this territory which would soon evolve into the Kingdom of France.
Otto III inherited his father’s imperialist views, seeing himself as a successor to Charlemagne. He made ecclesiastical appointments, including his cousin, Brun, as the first German pope (Gregory V). As Gregory’s successor, Otto appointed the Archbishop of Ravenna who encouraged Otto’s imperial ambitions, taking the name of Sylvester II as a parallel to Constantine the Great’s relationship with Sylvester I. Otto had no doubt about the authority of the emperor over the pope and denounced the Donation of Constantine as a forgery. Otto also had theocratic leanings, describing himself as ‘servus Jesu Christi‘ or ‘servus apostulorum‘ as well as Roman emperor. Intending to make Rome the capital of his empire he was nevertheless forced to leave the city in 1001. He gathered forces to regain the city but died suddenly in January 1002 at the age of 21.
After the death of the unmarried Otto III the one surviving male member of the Ottonian line (Henry IV of Bavaria, grandson of Otto I’s younger brother, Henry) succeeded to the throne of Germany as Henry II. There was some opposition to his succession but it was settled after a few months. In the meantime, Arduin of Ivrea and taken advantage of the situation to have himself named as King of Italy. In 1004, Henry invaded Italy, deposing Arduin and himself being crowned King of Italy (or of the Lombards). However, following Henry’s return to Germany, Arduin was able to regain control of his former territory until Henry’s second Italian expedition in 1014. Once more deposed, Arduin retired to his estates and died a year later. Henry, meanwhile, was crowned Emperor in Rome in February 1014.
Apart from an abortive expedition to southern Italy in 1022 against a resurgent Byzantine Empire, Henry II showed no interest in Italian affairs, to the extent of describing his regime as ‘renovatio regni Francorum‘ rather than the ‘renovatio imperii Romanorum‘ of his predecessors. Deeply religious, Henry brought ecclesiastics into the realm of secular adminstration and continued the practice of making ecclesiastical appointments himself. He was also an early promoter of church reform. Married but apparently celibate, Henry II died childless in 1024, bringing an end to the Ottonian dynasty.
Following the extinction of the direct Ottonian line, Conrad the Salic was elected King of Germany as Conrad II. His election was contested but the dispute was resolved by the end of 1026. Conrad continued the Ottonian policy of centralising power into his own hands, for example by appointing his own men to duchies that had fallen vacant (or where he had removed the incumbent). For much of his reign, he was occupied with affairs in the east – Poland, Bohemia and Hungary. In 1034, he successfully incorporated the Kingdom of Burgundy into the Empire. Not interested in religious issues per se, Conrad nonetheless claimed authority over the church and used ecclesiastical appointments as a counterweight to the political power of the great magnates.
Just as the political vacuum caused by the death of Otto III had allowed Italian discontent with German rule to manifest itself in the claiming of the crown of Italy by Arduin of Ivrea, so the death of Henry II allowed another northern Italian magnate, Ulrich-Manfred, Marquess of Turin, to lead efforts to find an alternative to Conrad II. Overtures were made to a number of French princes but the efforts failed and Conrad’s rule in Italy was confirmed by his coronation as King of Italy in 1026 and as Emperor a year later. However, Conrad’s interventions in Italy were few, leaving the administration of the territory to a network of ecclesiastical and lay elites rather than via appointed royal officials. Of particular importance was the de constitutio feudi of 1037, an edict which gave to minor nobility the same right as higher nobility to pass on their fiefs to their heirs. His reign also saw the beginning of the process of church reform which was to cause severe political problems in the decades which followed. Conrad died in 1039 and was succeeded by his son, Henry III.
Henry III was extremely pious, organising events at which he publicly confessed his sins while encouraging others to do the same. He gave a major impetus to the movement for church reform which had begun during the reigns of his immediate predecessors. Henry’s position as King of Germany was never seriously challenged but he did have to spend much time and effort in dealing with dissent and rebellion in both the eastern and western regions of the kingdom. As a result, his interventions in Italian affairs were limited but had long lasting effects.
In 1046, he made an expedition to Italy to be crowned Emperor. At this time, there were three rival popes in Rome. Henry removed them all and appointed the German Bishop of Bamberg as Clement II. Before his death in 1056, Henry appointed three more popes, all Germans. These popes and their immediate successors were to succeed in turning the papacy into a major political power in Europe, one of whom would bring Henry’s son, Henry IV to submission. Following his coronation, Henry broke up the Lombard principality of Salerno – Capua and made the Norman rulers of Apulia and Aversa direct imperial vassals, further weakening the power of Guaimar, the Prince of Salerno.
In 1053, the army that Henry had sent to help Pope Leo IX in his campaign against the Normans was destroyed at Civitate, the Pope himself being taken prisoner. Henry’s last intervention in Italian affairs was the arrest and imprisonment of Beatrice, widow of Boniface III of Tuscany, who had married Henry’s enemy Godfrey the Bearded of Lorraine. Beatrice and her daughter Matilda were released shortly afterwards due to the political pressures under which Henry found himself. He died in October at 1056, having entrusted his six-year-old son, also Henry, to the care of Pope Victor II.
Henry IV’s long reign was marked by his attempts to impose his authority on both his own aristocracy in Germany and the papacy. He failed badly in both.
Following the death of Victor II in 1057, Henry’s mother, Agnes of Poitou, was made regent but, unable to govern effectively, she was replaced in 1062 by Anno, Archbishop of Cologne. During her time as regent, Agnes had been forced to cede lands to powerful nobles. Upon his majority, Henry attempted to retrieve these lands as well as assert his authority as a ruler appointed by God. As a result, there were almost constant conflicts in Germany between him and various coalitions of nobles and prelates.
In parallel with events in Germany, Henry found himself embroiled in a conflict with the papacy over church reform, one of many incidents in the long-running dispute between pope and emperor. Henry’s insistence on making ecclesiastical appointments led to his excommunication by Pope Gregory VII in 1076. His support in Germany collapsing, Henry was forced to make amends to Gregory at Canossa in January 1077. However, this could not prevent his opponents in Germany from electing Henry’s former ally Rudolf of Rheinfelden as king in his place; Gregory VII recognised Rudolf as king. Hostilities continued until 1080 when Rudolf died of wounds received in battle. Hermann of Salm was elected anti-king in his place but he never achieved a level of acceptance approaching that of Rudolf. Some months before the latter’s death, faced with Gregory’s continued support for his rival, Henry had convened two councils which had declared Gregory deposed and had elected an anti-pope, Clement III, in his place.
Taking advantage of the hiatus in the conflict with his German opponents caused by the death of Rudolf of Rheinfelden, from 1081 Henry made a number of expeditions into Italy, with mixed results. However, in early 1084, he was able to take possession of Rome. Gregory VII had to leave and Henry was crowned Emperor by Clement III. There were also ultimately unsuccessful campaigns against the Norman Robert Guiscard and the Countess Matilda of Tuscany, both allies of Gregory VII. For the remainder of the 1080s in Germany, there were outbreaks of hostilities interspersed with negotiations for settlement. The deaths of Gregory VI (1085) and Hermann of Salm (1088) improved Henry’s position but he was not able to bring the conflict to a successful conclusion.
Seeking to increase opposition to Henry in Germany, in 1089 Pope Urban II arranged a marriage between Matilda and Welf, heir to the Duke of Bavaria (also Welf). In retaliation, Henry attacked Matilda’s holdings in 1090. Initially very successful, by the end of 1092 he had to withdraw, leaving Matilda with all her territories. Henry suffered a major blow in 1093 when Matilda and her allies convinced his heir, Conrad, to break with his father and be crowned King of Italy. Henry was then trapped in NE Italy and, further, was deserted by his second wife, Eupraxia of Kiev. Henry’s fortunes improved with the breakdown of Matilda’s marriage and the Welfs’ changing of sides. This permitted him to return to Germany where a number of notables returned to his allegiance. In 1098, these nobles deposed Conrad as King of Italy in favour of his younger brother, the future Henry V. Deserted by his allies, Conrad died in 1101. Despite tentative moves for a reconciliation between pope and emperor, Urban II’s successor, Paschal II confirmed Henry’s excommunication in April 1101.
Small scale unrest continued in Germany but matters were brought to a head in December 1104 by the desertion of his father by the future Henry V. Notables rallied to him, as did Paschal II. Captured by his son’s forces, Henry abdicated in favour of his son in December 1105. He escaped from his confinement and raised forces to contest his son. He gained a number of victories but died unexpectedly in August 1106.
Having ensured his undisputed succession by joining forces with those opposing his father’s absolutionist policies, in the initial years of his reign Henry V acted by consensus. The names of important nobles appeared as witnesses to royal charters and all acts of government, even the nomination of bishops, were done consilio principum. Such nobles were used more in government administration, replacing the royal officials of low birth (ministerales) who had been used by Henry IV. There were inconclusive negotiations with Paschal II aimed at ending the papal-imperial dispute but, in the meantime, Henry continued to make investitures which, as Henry was backed by the powerful German prelates, Paschal was unable to prevent.
With Germany secure, in 1110 Henry embarked on an expedition to Italy to settle matters with the pope. An agreement between them by which Henry would give up investiture in exchange for receiving back all the secular powers and income which ecclesiastics had received from the king was violented rejected by the clergy and Henry’s coronation was cancelled. Paschal having refused to return the right to investiture, Henry had him imprisoned until he agreed. Henry was eventually crowned in April 1111. He returned to Germany after concluding an agreement with the Countess Matilda concerning the disposition of her territories after her death.
Henry’s actions in Rome were condemned by the church, especially by the Archbishop of Vienne, himself a future pope. In 1112, Paschal II withdrew the concessions extracted from him the previous year. Henry also began to revert to the use of ministerales, thus incurring the opposition of powerful magnates such as Lothar of Saxony and Adalbert, Archbishop of Mainz (a former ally). By 1115, he had lost control of Saxony and had been badly defeated at Andernach while trying to put down a revolt by the citizens of Cologne.
Despite the weakness of his position in Germany, in 1116 Henry launched a second expedition to Italy to take possession of the lands of Countess Matilda who had died during the previous year; he remained in Italy until 1118. Paschal II died in January 1118 and his successor, Gelasius II, excommunicated Henry. However, Gelasius was forced into exile and died the following year. In the meantime, Henry had appointed an antipope, Gregory VIII. Gelasius II was succeeded by the Archbishop of Vienne mentioned above who took the name Calixtus II. Back in Germany, in 1121 Henry managed to achieve an armistice with the principal magnates at the cost of relinquishing a lot of his authority to them. This also opened the door for negotiations with Calixtus II to settle permanently the investiture controversy. The Concordat of Worms (September 1122) made a distinction between the spiritual and temporal functions of a clerical magnate. The former would be conferred by the clergy itself and the latter by the king. The whole was, however, a diplomatic fudge with each party being able to interpret the terms of the concordat in their own way. Henry V died in May 1125 with no legitimate issue from his marriage with Matilda of England, making the Salian dynasty extinct. Lothar of Supplinburg was chosen as his successor.
Lothar owed his election as king to Archbishop Adalbert of Mainz who persuaded the princes to reject Frederick of Hohenstaufen. As Henry V’s material and political heir, Frederick represented a threat to the gains made by Henry’s opponents in the final years of his reign, especially in the area of the relationship between church and state. Lothar adhered to the terms of the Concordat of Worms, even to the extent of requesting the Pope to ratify his election as king. Lothar was also attractive to those opposed to hereditary rule. As a fifty-year-old man whose only child, a daughter who had been born ten years earlier, he was unlikely to found a dynasty and the process of selecting his successor would be genuinely electoral.
Throughout his twelve year reign, Lothar was in constant conflict, principally with the Hohenstaufens but also other notables. He was also much involved with events on the eastern border of the kingdom. In 1127, Conrad of Hohenstaufen, Frederick’s younger brother, was elected by Lothar’s opponents to be King of Germany. The following year, Conrad went to Italy and had himself crowned King of Italy. Neither move was successful and he abandoned the titles in 1134 when the Hohenstaufens belatedly made peace with Lothar.
In view of his constant problems in Germany, Lothar only intervened twice in Italy. Upon the death of Honorius II in 1130, a divided college of cardinals elected rival popes: Innocent II and Anacletus II, each backed by a powerful noble Roman family. Innocent was forced into exile. However he gained the support of the kings of France and England, as well as Lothar who mounted an expedition to reinstate Innocent. Lothar was crowned Emperor in Rome by Innocent even though Anacletus remained in occupation of the greater part of the city, including St. Peter’s. Once Lothar’s forces withdrew, Innocent was again forced out and the schism was only resolved by the death of Anacletus in 1138, shortly after the death of Lothar himself.
At the time of his coronation as Emperor, Lothar had come to an agreement with the Pope over the disposition of Matilda of Tuscany’s lands, which she had variously bequeathed to the Church and the Emperor. Lothar was granted Matilda’s lands in return for an annual payment of 100 pounds of silver, with the lands being returned to the papacy on Lothar’s death. The fief was then passed to Lothar’s son-in-law, Henry the Proud, Duke of Bavaria. However, the dispute between pope and emperor over the rights to Matildas’s lands would subsequently reopen on a number of occasions.
In 1136, Innocent II appealed to Lothar looking for assistance against Roger II of Sicily who had invaded Apulia. Lothar’s forces wrung some concessions from Roger but, as was usually the case with imperial intervention to Italy, they did not survive the withdrawal of Lothar’s forces and his death in 1137.
Just as Henry V had tried to ensure the election of his nephew Frederick of Swabia by making him his heir, so the heirless Lothar tried to influence the election of his own successor by endowing his son-in-law, Henry the Proud, with the duchies of Bavaria and Saxony. Like Henry, Lothar failed. Concerned that Henry the Proud was too powerful, a minority of princes, led by Archbishop Albero of Trier, elected Conrad of Hohenstaufen instead. Although never seriously challenged as King, Conrad was obliged to spend the majority of his reign in dealing with the conflicting claims of different princes to important territories. Chief among these were Henry the Proud and his son Henry the Lion. He also had to deal with issues in the east: Poland, Bohemia and Hungary. In 1147, Conrad raised an army to take part in the Second Crusade but his army was comprehensively defeated by the Turks at the second battle of Dorylaeum. After this battle, he made an alliance with the Byzantine Emperor, Manuel Comnenus against Roger II of Sicily, whose troops had invaded Byzantine possessions in the Balkans but this never produced any results as Conrad was too preoccupied by events in Germany. In fact, Roger II had an arrangement with Henry the Lion, paying him 100 marks a year to ensure that Conrad would never be able to mount an expedition to Italy. As a result, when Conrad died in 1152, he had never been crowned Emperor, the first king of Germany not to be so since Otto the Great.
In nominating his successor, Conrad passed over his surviving six year old son, Frederick, in favour of his adult nephew Frederick of Swabia (Barbarossa). His choice was rapidly endorsed by a small group of German nobles; Barbarossa was elected king on 4 March 1152 and crowned five days later. In addition to avoiding another minority kingship, the selection of Barbarossa was an attempt at uniting the German nobility as his mother was the sister of Henry the Proud, Conrad III’s rival for king.
The early years of Barbarossa’s reign were taken up with his coming to accommodations with the German elites, especially with Henry the Lion to whom he returned the Duchy of Bavaria which had been taken from Henry’s father by Conrad III. He imposed his authority over the German church, even to the extent of subverting the Concordat of Worms with regard to ecclesiastical appointments. Barbarossa did not actually make investitures himself but indicated clearly his preferred candidates to the ecclesiastics who did. Having refused previous requests for intervention in Italy, Barbarossa finally mounted an expedition there in October 1154.
Halting in Piacenza, Barbarossa took some limited action against rebellious towns but was took weak to attack Milan. After having initially refused to take part in the ritual which implied his subserviance to the pope, Barbarossa was forced to concede the point in order to be crowned Emperor by Adrian IV (June 1155). His attempts to subdue the Roman commune failed and he returned north of the Alps. He declined to provide assistance to Adrian in his campaign against William I of Sicily (which failed), beginning the estrangement between emperor and pope which would later come to dominate affairs in Italy and beyond.
In Barbarossa’s absence, the Milanese took the opportunity to strengthen their control over the northern towns but the city fell to him during his second Italian expedition which began in July 1158. The Diet of Roncaglia confirmed Barbarossa’s maximalist position with regard to imperial rights and authority but the dissatisfied towns rose in revolt, resulting in a six month siege of Crema (July 1159 – January 1160). Barbarossa’s claims had worsened relations with Adrian IV but the death of the latter in September provoked a full blown crisis which lasted for decades.
Having few military resources of its own, the papacy had always had to rely on outside assistance for protection. Although the Byzantine emperors still haboured thoughts of recovering their lost territories in Italy, the only realistic options for the papacy were the German emperors or the Normans of Sicily. Following the death of Adrian IV, a pro-Norman group of cardinals rapidly elected Alexander III. However, shortly afterwards, a second group (including some from the original group) elected a pro-imperial antipope, Victor IV. Alexander refused Barbarossa’s attempts at arbitration and both sides appealed for support (inter alia), the kings of France and England. Over time, Alexander gained the support of all except for Germany and the Byzantine Empire. However, without material support, he was forced to exile himself to France. In the meantime, the northern Italian cities had again risen in revolt. Milan was sacked and razed and all were obliged to accept the terms of the Diet of Roncaglia.
Barbarossa returned north to gain support against Alexander but was not successful. He returned to Italy in October 1163 with a smaller army than before. Faced with a new revolt by Verona, Padua and Vicenza, Barbarossa was forced to come to terms with them. The antipope Victor IV died in April 1164 and Barbarossa appointed a new antipope (Paschal III) but he received little support, even in Germany. Alexander III was able to return to Rome, Barbarossa having returned to Germany. The death of William I of Sicily and the succession of his 12 year old son, William II, under the regency of his mother did not change the Norman anti-imperial policy.
A fourth expedition to Italy began in October 1166 and in May 1167, Barbarossa’s army routed the Roman militia and occupied Rome. Alexander III was forced to flee to Benevento but Barbarossa’s army was decimated by disease and he was forced to withdraw again.
In Barbarossa’s absence, the Lombard League was formed with financial assistance from both the Normans and the Byzantine Empire. Barbarossa’s second antipope Paschal III died in September 1168 and although a small group of anti-Alexandrine cardinals appointed a third (Calixtus III), he gained little or no support, even in Germany. Attempts at reconciliation with Alexander failed and in September 1174, Barbarossa embarked on his fifth Italian expedition. This time, his army was weaker than before due to the absence of the forces of Henry the Lion with whom Barbarossa was in dispute over the disposition of the Matildine lands. A long and unsuccessful siege of the new city of Alessandria ended in April 1175. A year later, Barbarossa’s army was heavily defeated at Legnano (May 1176) and, in a series of treaties, he was forced to come to terms with his enemies. At Anagni, Alexander was recognised as pope with the right to appoint the prefect of Rome. Ecclesiastical possessions seized under the schism were returned and a number of ecclesiastical appointments were confirmed (including the schismatically appointed Archbishops of Mainz and Cologne). The Empress Beatrice and Henry VI (Barbarossa’s wife and eldest son) also agreed to these terms and their titles were recognised by the Pope, with coronation in due course. There was to be a fifteen year truce with Sicily and a six year one with the Lombard towns. The Emperor was also to conclude peace with the Byzantines and all other papal allies. The negotiations at Anagni were conducted only between representatives of the Emperor and the Pope. A second conference was held in Venice in 1177 in which Sicily and the Lombard towns took part. This confirmed the terms of the Anagni agreement. Further negotiations with the Lombard towns took place in 1183 and an agreement was made in Constance in June. The agreement acknowledged the traditional right of imperial sovereignty but the extended claims made at the Diet of Roncaglia were withdrawn. The right of the cities to elect their own consuls or podestà was recognised, as well as the ability to administer justice, raise taxes and fortify their towns and castles. There was a general amnesty for faults committed and the newly created town of Alessandria was admitted as an imperial city.
In 1173, in a move to detach him from his alliance with Alexander III, Barbarossa had proposed to William II of Sicily a marriage between his son, Henry VI and William’s heir presumptive, his aunt Constance. William rejected the idea but, with peace agreed at Venice, Barbarossa re-opened the matter and this time William agreed. Constance and Henry VI were married in January 1186.
Disputes between Barbarossa and successive popes continued for a number of years over the disposition of the Matildine lands and over Lucius III’s and Urban III’s refusal to crown Henry VI as co-emperor with Barbarossa. The final years of Barbarossa’s reign were dominated by problems in Germany and in May 1189 he joined the Third Crusade, leaving Henry VI as his regent. In June 1190, he was drowned while crossing a river in Asia Minor.
Henry VI’s seven year reign was marked by his attempts to stamp his authority not only over Germany and Italy (as had his predecessors) but also to extend it elsewhere. William II of Sicily died in November 1189 and Henry VI claimed the throne by right of his wife. However, in January 1190, a section of the Sicilian elite elected as king Tancred of Lecce, an illegitimate son of Roger of Apulia, the son of Roger II who had predeceased his father. Conflict broke out in mainland Norman Italy between the supporters of Tancred and those of rival claimant Roger of Andria who were allied to supporters of Henry VI. In May 1190, a German army crossed into Norman territory but was defeated by the pro-Tancred forces and forced to withdraw.
In Sicily, matters were complicated by the arrival in September 1190 of the forces of Richard I and Philip Augustus on their way to the Third Crusade. Disputes between the two kings and Tancred were resolved by a treaty in March 1191 in which they agreed to support Tancred for as long as their forces were in Sicily. However, Richard I left a month later.
Events in Germany (notably the activities of Henry the Lion who had returned from exile in 1187) had prevented Henry VI from intervening personally in Italy but in Spring 1191 he entered Italy with an army and made his way south. On 15 April 1191, he was crowned Emperor by the newly elected Pope Celestine III. Having crossed into Norman territory, Henry had some initial successes but his progress was halted by the need to besiege Naples. Failing to take the city, he returned to Germany, where Henry the Lion was still causing problems, with backing from the Pope, Tancred and Richard I. Celestine’s increasing anti-imperial stance also led to his investing Tancred with the kingdom of Sicily in late 1191.
Henry’s interference in the selection of a new bishop of Liège resulted in serious conflict which kept him in Germany throughout 1192. One of the candidates for this post, Albert of Brabant, was murdered in November 1192. This act stirred up considerable opposition to Henry who was suspected of being complicit in it. This further worsened relations between Henry and Celestine as did Henry’s behaviour over Richard I. Returning from the crusade, the English king had been captured by Leopold of Austria in December 1192. In February 1193, Leopold handed Richard over to Henry who demanded a huge ransom for his release. Terms were agreed in June 1193 but Richard was not finally released until February the following year. Having come to terms with the family of Albert of Brabant and also with Henry the Lion, Henry was now free to return to Sicily. In Henry’s absence, Tancred had campaigned successfully against imperial forces in mainland Italy but in February 1194 he died, leaving no one to take his place. As a result, Henry’s advance south turned into a procession and on Christmas Day 1194 he was crowned King of Sicily in Palermo. A day later, his wife Constance gave birth to their only child, the future Emperor Frederick II. A conference at Bari in the spring of 1195 gave the government of Sicily to the Empress Constance and Germans were appointed to key posts in both Sicily and central Italy, including Tuscany.
After the takeover of Sicily, Henry did not look for any further territorial acquisitions but he did seek to increase his influence and authority in other ways. One of the conditions of Richard I’s release was that he surrender the kingdom of England to Henry and receive it back as an imperial fief, making Richard Henry’s vassal. Richard was encouraged to continue his enmity towards Philip Augustus; Henry’s intention being that, ultimately, France would also fall under his influence. It was also suggested that Richard be enfeoffed with the Kingdom of Burgundy so that he might be able to attack Aragon. With regard to the eastern Mediterranean, Henry married his younger brother Philip to a Byzantine princess with a view to an eventual fusion between the Western and Eastern empires. Events in Constantinople prevented this from happening. However, Henry did award crowns to the rulers of both Little Armenia and Cyprus.
Henry’s other initiative at increasing his authority was his attempt to make his titles hereditary. The Kingdom of Sicily was hereditary (and also outside of the Empire) but the Kingdoms of Germany and Italy were elective. Henry’s intention was that they should all be merged into a single entity which would be hereditary to him and his heirs. By offering concessions to the German elites at the Diet of Würzburg (April 1196), Henry was able to get a certain measure of agreement to his wishes but opposition from major players (e.g. the Archbishop of Cologne) prevented its implementation. Henry then turned to Celestine III.
In June 1196, Henry travelled to Rome to try and convince the Pope to agree to his plans. He offered Celestine considerable financial concessions and even proposed the idea that the entire empire would be a papal fief. As a further measure to reduce the influence of the German elites opposed to him, Henry also asked Celestine to crown his infant son Frederick as King of Germany, an act normally carried out by the Archbishop of Cologne. Already alarmed at the extent of imperial power in Italy, Celestine temporised. In October, Henry’s ideas were brought up at the Diet of Erfurt where there was even more opposition to them. Henry was forced to concede and Frederick was crowned in the customary way in Frankfurt (December 1196).
As part of his strategy with regard to the Eastern Mediterranean, in early 1195, Henry took the cross and persuaded a reluctant Celestine to support his action. Preparations for the crusade were severely disrupted in early 1197 by a rebellion in Italy against Henry’s harsh government, notably in Sicily but also in other parts of the peninsula. It is possible that both Pope Celestine and the Empress Constance were implicated in this revolt. The rising was put down with great severity. In early September 1197, the crusading army left for the East with Henry to follow but he died of dysentery on 28 September.
Otto IV (Welf)
Frederick II
The founder of the Ottonian dynasty, Henry the Fowler, had been elected King of Germany in 919, following the death of Conrad I, the first non-Carolingian ruler of Eastern Francia. A Saxon, Henry was the first non-Frankish king of the region. Henry had only being elected by Frankish and Saxon nobles and it took him until 925 to come to accommodations with the rulers in other parts of Germany who had been very rebellious in Conrad’s reign (as had he). These were usually accomplished by negotiation rather than by military means and gave subordinate rulers some autonomy. Nevertheless, they were tied to Henry as vassals leaving no room for doubt that he was their overlord. In similar vein, he came to agreements with the rulers of the other successor states of the Carolingian Empire. These also were allowed to rule in their own way while acknowledging Henry as their overlord. By the terms of his agreement with Henry, Rudolf II of Burgundy surrendered to Henry his claims to the throne of Italy. As would be the case with his successors, Henry was also much occupied with affairs on his eastern border either in attempts to extend his territory or defensive measures against foreign incursions, particularly the Magyars. There can be no doubting Henry’s imperial ambitions; he was, in fact, planning to go to Rome to be crowned when he died in 936. Significantly, although his lands and possessions were divided amongst his sons, there was no division of of the kingship, as had been the case with the Carolingians. His eldest son, Otto I, succeeded him.
Otto continued his process of accumulating power in the kingship but used his military superiority to coerce rather than negotiate, as Henry had done. He was able to continue the domination over West Francia and Burgundy and began to take an interest in Italian affairs, for example in providing a refuge for Berengar of Ivrea, culminating in his intervention in 951, described above. However, as was often the case with later German rulers, Otto was obliged to return to Germany to counter rebellions against his rule and threats from outside. In this he was successful, being able to unite the German nobles behind him against a new invasion by the Magyars who were decisively beaten at Lechfeld (955). His homeland secure, Otto was able to turn again to Italian affairs leading to his removal from power of Berengar II in 960and his subsequent coronation as Emperor. This epitomised the growth in Otto’s power. In 951, Otto had negotiated with Rome to be crowned Emperor but his efforts failed in the face of opposition from the effective ruler of Rome, Alberic. It was Alberic’s son, Pope John XII, who called on Otto for help against Berengar and once this had been successfully provided, his coronation as Emperor was assured.
Some words about the long term consequences of Otto
Otto I did not seek election to crown of Italy – just took it.
Otto’s conflicts with the papacy/Rome – Ullmann 116ff.
Otto and Byzantine alliance/agreements (Riché notes 18)- unsuccessful interventions in the south (previous rulers not interested)
1002 Henry II2Numbered II in succession to Henry I of Germany (919-936) in dispute over succession to German thrones – only settled 1004
1002 Arduin of Ivrea elected King of Italy (had strong local support – and benefited from anti-German forces in Rome – Crescentius)
1004 Italian nobility rally to Henry – crowned King of Italy (separate crown) – returns to Germany – not back in Italy for a decade (lengthy conflict with Poles)
1013 – papal troubles in Rome (Crescentius) lead to invasion by Henry – traps Arduin in Ivrea (dies 1015) last native king of Italy until 1860
![]()
- 1The names below are convenient handles, not necessarily strict definitions. For example, the first part of the Ostrogoth period includes the seventeen years between the deposition by Odoacer of the last Western emperor (476) and Odoacer’s own overthrow by Theodoric, King of the Ostrogoths in 493). Also, Hohenstaufen rule in Italy continued beyond the period covered here. ↩︎
- 2Numbered II in succession to Henry I of Germany (919-936) ↩︎