Notes: Kristeller Humanism
Source: Kristeller, P., Humanism in Schmitt C. et al. (eds.) The Cambridge History of Renaissance Philosophy. (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1988) pp.111-138
Any comments in square brackets are mine rather than the author’s.
| Page | Note |
|---|---|
| 113 | Humanism is a contested term. In the 19th and early 20th centuries, 'Renaissance humanism' went concerned and study and imitation of antiquity, ultimately derived from 'studici humanitatis'. |
| 113 | Humanity' was used by Cicero, Gellius and others and the term was revived by Petrarch, Salutati and others. By the mid-15th century it meant study of grammatica, rhetorica, poetica, historia and philosophia moralis |
| 113 | It did not include logic or the quadrivium (arithmetica, geometra, astronomia and musica); nor fine arts as defined in the 18th century: the visual arts, music, dancing, gardening). |
| 114 | Also excluded were: theology, jurisprudence, medicine and philosophy (logic, natural philosophy, metaphysics). It was not the totality of learning but a subset. |
| 114 | Humanists were best known as educators: Latin in all aspects, to some extent Greek – study of ancient writers (both Latin and Greek), verse and prose. |
| 114 | Guarino da Verona (Ferrara) and Vittorino da Feltre (Mantua). |
| 114 | The study of the humanities was considered the best basis for intellectual and moral standards and taste for future leaders of society. The concept lasted until the 20th century. |
| 115 | Humanists were more influential in secondary schools but were not absent from universities. They grew in influence over time (late 15th and early 16th centuries). |
| 115 | Humanists were also found as senior civil servants as they were skilled in Latin composition, not only in Italy but elsewhere in Europe. |
| 116 | Humanists were often commissioned to write the histories of states. Apart from officials, some rulers were also humanists – as were churchmen, bankers and merchants (i.e. people who were not dependent on humanism to earn their keep). Also lawyers and physicians and people in the book trade (copyists). |
| 117 | Humanists invented new scripts: Roman (Poggio) and Italic (Niccoli?), superseding Gothic. |
| 117 | Printing was invented around 1410 (came to Italy in 1465) but was slow to spread, thus maintaining the need for manual copyists. |
| 118 | Humanists oversaw the publication of their own texts and supervised the publication of ancient ones (Aldus Manutus). Also Erasmus – connections with publishers helped the distribution of their own work. |
| 119 | The role of humanists in discovery of old texts and correcting them: Petrarch, Boccaccio, Salutati, Poggio. These were not real discoveries since they had been in monasteries since Carolingian times but had been neglected since. Humanists gave them wide circulation. Pre-1350, virtually no Greek texts in the West. Those that were there were brought back by Western visitors to the East or Byzantines is fleeing the Turks. There was much editing and glossing of texts... |
| 120 | ... plus full commentaries. Knowledge of Greek was never as comprehensive as Latin – there was no indigenous tradition of Greek and it was not a working language. |
| 120 | Greek texts were translated into Latin to give them wider circulation, encouraged by important patrons (Nicholas V and his successors, the Medici). Poetry, philosophy, scientific and mathematical texts. A small amount of Hebrew and Arabic. |
| 121 | The reading public was laid people as well as specialists; there were even vernacular translations. New works were created using humanist models by contemporary authors (e.g. Montaigne). Compilation of dictionaries and other linguistic aids. |
| 122 | Classical Latin was used as a model to clean up contemporary written and spoken Latin (i.e. mediaeval Latin). The downside was a refusal sometimes to cast aside neologisms and style was privileged over content and meaning. Importance of rhetoric (practical use by politicians etc.). |
| 123 | Speeches (orations) and official letters – sometimes sermons. |
| 124 | Official correspondence had to use mediaeval models but the language, vocabulary and style were improved. Private letters were modelled on Seneca, Pliny the Younger and Cicero. Knowledge of ancient texts and style was used to expose forgeries [Valla] – the beginnings of historiography. |
| 125 | Many treatises on moral or other philosophical problems – preference for invective and dialogue. Dialogues were modelled on Cicero rather than Plato. There was not much narrative prose but lots of Latin poetry: epigrams, elegies, epics, odes à la Horace not so much. |
| 126 | Few tragedies in Latin but lots of comedies as these influenced vernacular works (Ariosto, Ronsard, Spenser). Political theory and literary criticism. |
| 126 | There was much imitation of ancient models but, what was new, humanists took seriously their own feelings and preferences – much subjectivity – which had not been present in classical writings. Was this the source of the individuality stressed by Burckhardt? |
| 127 | The origins of humanism are in Petrarch but also scholars in northern Italy in the late 13th and early 14th centuries: Albertino Mussato da Padova, Giovanni del Virgilio (Bologna). |
| 127 | Various possible explanations for the rise of humanism: city republics looking back to Rome as their model rather than the feudal culture of the rest of Europe. Only humanism was a merger between the Bologna tradition of rhetoric (training for lawyers and civil servants) and… |
| 128 | … the study by grammarians of ancient writers (initially more in France than in Italy). This declined in northern Europe about the same time as it grew in Italy. |
| 128 | The importance of Petrarch whose international prestige raised the status of humanist studies: his poems but also treatises and letters and invectives… |
| 129 | … Very pro-humanities as opposed to sciences. Defence of the solitary life (for laymen as well as clerics). Much influenced by Seneca and the recently discovered letters of Cicero. Not a grammarian in the ordinary sense of the term – but nonetheless… Influenced by Plato rather than Aristotle. |
| 130 | In Petrarch's later years and after his death, his work was carried on by his friends such as Giovanni da Ravenna, Salutati and Boccaccio. Boccaccio discovered works by Tacitus and promoted translations from Greek. Salutati was Chancellor of Florence. His private correspondence promoted active life Salutati was also responsible for bringing Manuel Chrysoloras to Florence. |
| 130 | 15th century was the high point of Italian humanism. Discovery, diffusion and commentary on many works – the rise of Greek scholarship (importance of exiles from the Byzantine Empire). |
| 131 | Poliziano and Ermolao Barbaro as important Greek scholars. The civic humanism of Baron et al confined to early 15th century Florence. It was only one aspect of humanism. |
| 131 | By the late 15th and the 16th centuries, humanists expanded their studies into other areas: philosophy, science, medicine, theology. |
| 132 | In 16th century, humanism lost ground but did continue. Increase in the use of the vernacular. The 16th century was the great age for humanism outside of Italy: Reuchlin, Erasmus, Budé, More, Vives. |
| 133 | Erasmus promoted Christian humanism as opposed to the Italian pagan humanism. Christian humanism is only a subset of humanism in general but most, if not all, humanists were Christians. By the late 16th and 17th centuries, humanism was well spread all over Europe with France and the Low Countries to the fore. |
| 133 | Renaissance humanism was essentially a scholarly, educational and literary movement with many concerns of which philosophy was not necessarily the most important one. |
| 133 | Much of the philosophical literature of the Renaissance was not down to humanists but to Aristotelian's with scholastic training. |
| 134 | However, there were also Platonist metaphysicians (the Neoplatonism of Ficino) as well as original thinkers such as Nicholas of Cusa, Bruno and Francis Bacon. |
| 134 | Humanism was influence in some areas of philosophy, especially moral philosophy (this was the only part of philosophy recognised as part of the humanities). |
| 135 | Other areas of philosophy were not influenced by humanists per se but by individual humanists. Humanists also influenced other areas. For example, Alberti (architecture), Giorgio Valla (mathematics). |
| 135 | The making available of ancient texts also meant that humanists influence thought in other areas: mathematics, medicine, botany. Greek commentaries on Aristotle altered Aristotelian thought, leading to the questioning of mediaeval Aristotelianism. |
| 136 | Increased interest in other ancient schools of thought: Stoicism, Epicureanism, Scepticism. Humanists had influence on the style and pattern of philosophical literature. Their rules for Latin composition, syntax, vocabulary were transferred to vernacular languages. |
| Page | Note |
![]()